3. For in that case too,
argumentative men might by plausible reasoning upset our faith, so that
we should not think that statement true which Holy Scripture delivers
concerning the material creation, when it asserts that all existing
things have their beginning of being from God. For those who abide by
the contrary view maintain that matter is co-eternal with God, and
employ in support of their own doctrine some such arguments as these.
If God is in His nature simple and immaterial, without quantity Reading, with some of Forbes’ mss., ἄποσος, which
seems on the whole the better reading so far as sense is
concerned. ἄποιος may be the result of a sense of the awkwardness of employing
both ἄποσος and ἀμεγέθης: but further on in the section we find ἄποσος where the
mss. seem to agree. Further, the connecting
particles seem to show a closer connection of sense between
ἀποσὸς and
ἀμεγέθης than between ἀμεγέθης
and ἀσύνθετος, or size, or combination, and removed from
the idea of circumscription by way of figure, while all matter is
apprehended in extension measured by intervals, and does not escape the
apprehension of our senses, but becomes known to us in colour, and
figure, and bulk, and size, and resistance, and the other attributes
belonging to it, none of which it is possible to conceive in the Divine
nature,—what method is there for the production of matter from
the immaterial, or of the nature that has dimensions from that which is
unextended? for if these things are believed to have their existence
from that source, they clearly come into existence after being in Him
in some mysterious way; but if material existence was in Him, how can
He be immaterial while including matter in Himself? and similarly with
all the other marks by which the material nature is differentiated; if
quantity exists in God, how is God without quantity? if the compound
nature exists in Him, how is He simple, without parts and without
combination? so that the argument forces us to think either that He is
material, because matter has its existence from Him as a source; or, if
one avoids this, it is necessary to suppose that matter was imported by
Him ab extra for the making of the universe.