This was the declaration of faith proposed by Acacius,
and subscribed by himself and as many as adhered to his opinion, the
number of whom we have already given. When this had been read,
Sophronius bishop of Pompeiopolis in Paphlagonia, thus expressed
himself: ‘If to express a separate opinion day after day, be
received as the exposition of the faith, we shall never arrive at any
accurate understanding of the truth.’ These were the words of
Sophronius. And I firmly believe, that if the predecessors of these
prelates, as well as their successors, had entertained similar
sentiments in reference to the Nicene creed, all polemical debates
would have been avoided; nor would the churches have been agitated by
such violent and irrational disturbances. However let those judge who
are capable of understanding how these things are. At that time after
many remarks on all sides had been made both in reference to this
doctrinal statement, and in relation to the parties accused, the
assembly was dissolved. On the fourth day they all again met in the
same place, and resumed their proceedings in the same contentious
spirit as before. On this occasion Acacius expressed himself in these
words: ‘Since the Nicene creed has been altered not once only,
but frequently, there is no hindrance to our publishing another at this
time.’ To which Eleusius bishop of Cyzicus, replied: ‘The Synod is at present
convened not to learn what it had no previous knowledge of, nor to
receive a creed which it had not assented to before, but to confirm the
faith of the fathers, from which it should never recede, either in life
or death.’ Thus Eleusius opposing Acacius spoke meaning by
‘the faith of the fathers,’ that creed which had been
promulgated at Antioch. But surely he too might have been fairly
answered in this way: ‘How is it O Eleusius, that you call those
convened at Antioch “the fathers,” seeing that you do not
recognize those who were their fathers? The framers of the Nicene
creed, by whom the homoousian faith was acknowledged, have a far
higher claim to the title of “the fathers”; both as having
the priority in point of time, and also because those assembled at
Antioch were by them invested with the sacerdotal office. Now if those
at Antioch have disowned their own fathers, those who follow them are
unconsciously following parricides. Besides how can they have received
a legitimate ordination from those whose faith they pronounce unsound
and impious? If those, however, who constituted the Nicene Synod had
not the Holy Spirit which is imparted by the imposition of hands,
See Chrysostom, Homilies 9 and 27, on
Acts, and Hom. 1, on 2 Tim., for the belief of the
ancient Church in the descent of the Holy Spirit on the ordained in and
through ordination.
those at Antioch have not duly received the priesthood: for how could
they have received it from those who had not the power of conferring
it?’ Such considerations as these might have been submitted to
Eleusius in reply to his objections. But they then proceeded to another
question, connected with the assertion made by Acacius in his
exposition of the faith, ‘that the Son was like the
Father’; enquiring of one another in what this resemblance
consisted. The Acacian party affirmed that the Son was like the Father
as it respected his will only, and not his ‘substance’ or
‘essence’; but the rest maintained that the likeness
extended to both essence and will. In altercations on this point, the
whole day was consumed; and Acacius, being confuted by his own
published works, in which he had asserted that ‘the Son is in all
things like the Father,’ his opponents asked him ‘how do
you now deny the likeness of the Son to the Father as to his
“essence”?’ Acacius in reply said, that ‘no
author, ancient or modern, was ever condemned out of his own
writings.’ As they kept on their discussion on this matter to a
most tedious extent, with much acrimonious feeling and subtlety of
argument, but without any approach to unity of judgment, Leonas arose
and dissolved the council: and this was the conclusion of the Synod at
Seleucia. For on the following day [Leonas] being urged to do so would
not again meet with them. ‘I have been deputed by the
emperor,’ said he, ‘to attend a council where unanimity was
expected to prevail: but since you can by no means come to a mutual
understanding, I can no longer be present: go therefore to the church,
if you please, and indulge in vain babbling there.’ The Acacian
faction conceiving this decision to be advantageous to themselves, also
refused to meet with the others. The adverse party left alone met in
the church and requested the attendance of those who followed Acacius,
that cognizance might be taken of the case of Cyril, bishop of
Jerusalem: for that prelate had been accused long before, on what
grounds however I am unable to state. He had even been deposed, because
owing to fear, he had not made his appearance during two whole years,
after having been repeatedly summoned in order that the charges against
him might be investigated. Nevertheless, when he was deposed, he sent a
written notification to those who had condemned him, that he should
appeal to a higher jurisdiction: and to this appeal the emperor
Constantius gave his sanction. Cyril was thus the first and indeed only
clergyman who ventured to break through ecclesiastical usage, by
becoming an appellant, in the way commonly done in the secular courts
of judicature:
He was the only one, inasmuch as the General Synod
of Constantinople (381 a.d.) expressly forbade
all appeals from the ecclesiastical to the civil courts, attaching
severe penalties to the violation of its canon on this subject. Cf.
Canon 6 of Council of Constantinople. Hefele, Hist. of the Ch.
Councils, Vol. II. p. 364.
and he was now present at Seleucia, ready to be put upon his trial; on
this account the other bishops invited the Acacian party to take their
places in the assembly, that in a general council a definite judgment
might be pronounced on the case of those who were arraigned: for they
cited others also charged with various misdemeanors to appear before
them at the same time, who to protect themselves had sought refuge
among the partisans of Acacius. When therefore that faction persisted
in their refusal to meet, after being repeatedly summoned, the bishops
deposed Acacius himself, together with George of Alexandria, Uranius of
Tyre, Theodulus of Chæretapi in Phrygia, Theodosius of
Philadelphia in Lydia, Evagrius of the island of Mytilene, Leontius of
Tripolis in Lydia, and Eudoxius who had formerly been bishop of
Germanica, but had afterwards insinuated himself into the bishopric of
Antioch in Syria. They also deposed Patrophilus for contumacy, in not
having presented himself to answer a charge preferred against him by a
presbyter named Dorotheus. These they deposed: they also excommunicated
Asterius, Eusebius, Abgarus, Basilicus, Phœbus, Fidelis,
Eutychius, Magnus, and Eustathius; determining that they should not be restored to communion, until they
made such a defense as would clear them from the imputations under
which they lay. This being done, they addressed explanatory letters to
each of the churches whose bishops had been deposed. Anianus was then
constituted bishop of Antioch instead of Eudoxius: but the Acacians
having soon after apprehended him, he was delivered into the hands of
Leonas and Lauricius, by whom he was sent into exile. The bishops who
had ordained him being incensed on this account, lodged protests
against the Acacian party with Leonas and Lauricius, in which they
openly charged them with having violated the decisions of the Synod.
Finding that no redress could be obtained by this means, they went to
Constantinople to lay the whole matter before the emperor.