The Theophania contains much that is found also in other works of Eusebius. Large
portions of the first, second, and third books are contained in the Oratio de Laudibus Con-
stantini, nearly the whole of the fifth book is given in the Dem. Evang., while many passages
occur in the Præp. Evang.
These coincidences assist us in determining the date of the work. That it was written
after persecution had ceased and peace was restored to the Church, is clear from II. 76, III.
20, 79, V. 52. Lee decided that it was composed very soon after the close of the Diocletian
persecution, but Lightfoot has shown conclusively (p. 333) from the nature of the parallels
between it and other writings of Eusebius, that it must have been written toward the end of
his life, certainly later than the De Laud. Const. (335 a.d.), and indeed it is not improbable
that it remained unfinished at the time of his death.
III. Polemic Works.
Defense of Origen (᾽Απολογία ὑπὲρ ᾽Ωριγένους). This was the joint work of Eusebius
and Pamphilus, as is distinctly stated by Eusebius himself in his H. E. VI. 33, by Socrates,
H. E. III. 7, by the anonymous collector of the Synodical Epistles (Ep. 198), and by Photius,
Bibl. 118. The last writer informs us that the work consisted of six books, the first five of
which were written by Eusebius and Pamphilus while the latter was in prison, the last book
being added by the former after Pamphilus’ death (see above, p. 9). There is no reason to
doubt the statement of Photius, and we may therefore assign the first five books to the years
307–309, and assume that the sixth was written soon afterward. The Defense has perished,
with the exception of the first book, which was translated by Rufinus (Rufin. ad Hieron. I.
582), and is still extant in his Latin version. Rufinus ascribed this book expressly to Pamphilus,
and Pamphilus’ name alone appears in the translation. Jerome (Contra Ruf. I. 8; II. 15, 23;
III. 12) maintains that the whole work was written by Eusebius, not by Pamphilus, and accuses
Rufinus of having deliberately substituted the name of the martyr Pamphilus for that of the
Arianizing Eusebius in his translation of the work, in order to secure more favorable accept-
ance for the teachings of Origen. Jerome’s unfairness and dishonesty in this matter have
been pointed out by Lightfoot (p. 340). In spite of his endeavor to saddle the whole work
upon Eusebius, it is certain that Pamphilus was a joint author of it, and it is quite probable
that Rufinus was true to his original in ascribing to Pamphilus all the explanations which
introduce and connect the extracts from Origen, which latter constitute the greater part of
the book. Eusebius may have done most of his work in connection with the later books.
The work was intended as a defense of Origen against the attacks of his opponents (see
Eusebius’ H. E. VI. 33, and the Preface to the Defense itself). According to Socrates (H. E.
VI. 13), Methodius, Eustathius, Apollinaris, and Theophilus all wrote against Origen. Of
these only Methodius had written before the composition of the Defense, and he was expressly
attacked in the sixth book of that work, according to Jerome (Contra Ruf. I. 11). The wide
opposition aroused against Origen was chiefly in consequence not of his personal character,
56
Catalogue of his Works.