With regard to the state of things in the
ecclesiastical sphere during Gregory’s popedom, it may be
observed first, that there was now a comparative cessation for a time
of controversial warfare. The battle no longer raged over Arian,
Nestorian, Monophysite, or Pelagian heresies; the Monothelitic
controversy had not yet begun. Catholic orthodoxy, as defined by
the first four Councils, was accepted generally, and enforced by the
imperial power, with Gregory’s full approval of coercive measures
(see e.g. Lib. IX., Ep. 49; Lib. XI., Ep.
46) “Prayer
should ever be made for the life of our most pious and Christian lord
the Emperor, and his most tranquil consort, &c., in whose times the
mouths of heretics are silent, since, though their hearts seethe with
the madness of perverse opinion, they presume not in the time of the
catholic Emperor to utter the wrong things they think”
(Lib. IX., Ep. 49).; while outside the limits of the Empire
it was professed and upheld by the Frankish rulers of Gaul, and at
length at the commencement of Gregory’s reign accepted in Spain
by the Visigothic Reccared. The Lombards, indeed, with their king
Agilulph, were still Arians; but his queen Theodelinda, with whom
Gregory corresponded, was herself a devout Catholic. Hence he was
not called on to come forward prominently in the field of controversy,
for which indeed he does not appear to have been peculiarly
fitted. For, though able to state clearly, and give the received
reasons for, accepted dogmas, he nowhere evinces any great originality
of conception, or depth of insight of his own. He is content to
rest on authority; that especially of the four Councils, which he
regards as the unassailable bulwarks of the true faith (see I. 25; III.
10; IV. 37), or of ancient fathers of the Church. Nor does he
seem to have been well versed in the past history of controversy.
An instance of his imperfect knowledge in this regard is found in the
letters which he wrote after receiving from Cyriacus, the
newly-appointed bishop of Constantinople, his confession of faith, in
which Eudoxius, who had been prominent in the course of the Arian
controversy, was condemned. Gregory had never heard of this noted
heretic, though he had come across the name of a sect called Eudoxiani,
and, not finding his name in the Latin books he was able to consult at
Rome, he takes objection to his condemnation by Cyriacus (Lib.
VII., Ep. 4); and it was not till he had consulted Eulogius of
Alexandria, who was more learned than himself, that he was satisfied;
and this simply on being informed that ancient fathers of repute had
condemned this Eudoxius. “We know him (he writes) to
be manifestly slain, against whom our heroes have cast so many
darts” (VII. 34; VIII. 30). Again, in writing to the same
Eulogius against the sect of Agnoitæ, who taught a certain
limitation of our Lord’s human knowledge, he appears to draw all
his arguments from what he found in Augustine and other Latin Fathers,
and he rejoices to hear that Eulogius had found the Greek Fathers (whom
he himself, being wholly ignorant of Greek, was unable to consult)
consentient (Lib. X., Epp. 35, 39).