Now in saying these things we do
not intend to deny that the Father exists without generation, and we
have no intention of refusing to agree to the statement that the
Only-begotten God is generated;—on the contrary the latter has
been generated, the former has not been generated. But what He
is, in His own Nature, Who exists apart from generation, and
what He is, Who is believed to have been generated, we do not
learn from the signification of “having been generated,”
and “not having been generated.” For when we say
“this person was generated” (or “was not
generated”), we are impressed with a two-fold thought, having our
eyes turned to the subject by the demonstrative part of the phrase, and
learning that which is contemplated in the subject by the words
“was generated” or “was not
generated,”—as it is one thing to think of that which is,
and another to think of what we contemplate in that which is. But,
moreover, the word “is” is surely understood with
every name that is used concerning the Divine Nature,—as
“just,” “incorruptible,”
“immortal,” and “ungenerate,” and whatever else
is said of Him; even if this word does not happen to occur in the
phrase, yet the thought both of the speaker and the hearer surely makes
the name attach to “is,” so that if this word were
not added, the appellation would be uttered in vain. For instance (for
it is better to present an argument by way of illustration), when David
says, “God, a righteous judge, strong and patient Cf. Ps. vii. 8,” if “is” were not
understood with each of the epithets included in the phrase, the
enumerations of the appellations will seem purposeless and unreal, not
having any subject to rest upon; but when “is” is
understood with each of the names, what is said will clearly be of
force, being contemplated in reference to that which is. As, then, when
we say “He is a judge,” we conceive concerning Him some
operation of judgment, and by the “is” carry our minds to
the subject, and are hereby clearly taught not to suppose that the
account of His being is the same with the action, so also as a result
of saying, “He is generated (or ungenerate),” we divide our
thought into a double conception, by “is” understanding the
subject, and by “generated,” or “ungenerate,”
apprehending that which belongs to the subject. As, then, when we are
taught by David that God is “a judge,” or
“patient,” we do not learn the Divine essence, but one of
the attributes which are contemplated in it, so in this case too when
we hear of His being not generated, we do not by this negative
predication understand the subject, but are guided as to what we
must not think concerning the subject, while what He essentially is
remains as much as ever unexplained. So too, when Holy Scripture
predicates the other Divine names of Him Who is, and delivers to Moses
the Being without a name, it is for him who discloses the Nature of
that Being, not to rehearse the attributes of the Being, but by his
words to make manifest to us its actual Nature. For every name which
you may use is an attribute of the Being, but is not the
Being,—“good,” “ungenerate,”
“incorruptible,”—but to each of these
“is” does not fail to be supplied. Any one, then, who
undertakes to give the account of this good Being, of this ungenerate
Being, as He is, would speak in vain, if he rehearsed the attributes
contemplated in Him, and were silent as to that essence which he
undertakes by his words to explain. To be without generation is one of
the attributes contemplated in the Being, but the definition of
“Being” is one thing, and that of “being in some
particular way” is another; and this What
“this” means is not clear: it may be “the
Being,” but most probably is the distinction which S. Gregory is
pointing out between the Being and Its attributes, which he considers
has not been sufficiently recognized. has
so far remained untold and unexplained by the passages cited. Let him
then first disclose to us the names of the essence, and then divide the
Nature by the divergence of the appellations;—so long as what we
require remains unexplained, it is in vain that he employs his
scientific skill upon names, seeing that the names Reading τῶν
ὀνομάτων οὐκ
ὄντων with the Paris
editions. Oehler reads νοημάτων, but does not give any authority for the change.
have no separate existence.