rather than those who resemble you in their practices. You consider as belonging to you a
woman that believes in Manichæus, though she is a mother, rather than a Sibyl, though she
never marries. But you will say that many who are called Catholic Christians are adulterers,
robbers, misers, drunkards, and whatever else is contrary to sound doctrine. I ask if none
such are to be found in your company, which is almost too small to be called a company.
And because there are some among the Pagans who are not of this character, do you consider
them as better than yourselves? And yet, in fact, your heresy is so blasphemous, that even
your followers who are not of such a character are worse than the Pagans who are. It is
therefore no impeachment to sound doctrine, which alone is Catholic, that many wish to
take its name, who will not yield to its beneficial influence. We must bear in mind the true
meaning of the contrast which the Lord makes between the little company and the mass of
mankind, as spread over all the world; for the company of saints and believers is small, as
the amount of grain is small when compared with the heap of chaff; and yet the good grain
is quite sufficient far to outnumber you, good and bad together, for good and bad are both
strangers to the truth. In a word, we are not a schism of the Gentiles, for we differ from
them greatly for the better; nor are you, for you differ from them greatly for the worse.755
————————————
755 [Augustin’s exposure of the paganism of Manichæism is an admirable and effective piece of argumentum
ad hominem. That the Christianity of Augustin’s time was becoming paganized is undoubted, but Manichæism
was pure paganism.—A.H.N.]
450
Faustus repels the charge of sun-worship, and maintains that while the Manichæans…