Now such endeavours ἐπιχείρημα. and so Orat. i. §44. init. but infra.
§25. ἐπιχειρήματα
means more definitely reasonings or
argumentations. are
nothing else than an obvious token of their defect of reason ἀλογίας; an
allusion frequent in Athanasius, to the judicial consequence of their
denying the Word of God. Thus, just below, n. 3. “Denying the
Word” or Reason “of God, reason have they none.” Also
Orat. i. §35. fin. §40. init. §62. Orat.
ii. §7. init. Hence he so often calls the Arians “mad”
and “deranged;” e.g. “not aware how ‘mad’
their ‘reason’ is.” Orat. i.
§37., and a copying, as I have said, of Jewish
malignity. For the Jews too, when convicted by the Truth, and unable to
confront it, used evasions, such as, ‘What sign doest Thou, that
we may see and believe Thee? What dost Thou work John vi. 30.?
though so many signs were given, that they said themselves, ‘What
do we? for this man doeth many miracles Ib. xi. 47..’ In truth, dead men were raised, lame
walked, blind saw afresh, lepers were cleansed, and the water became
wine, and five loaves satisfied five thousand, and all wondered and
worshipped the Lord, confessing that in Him were fulfilled the
prophecies, and that He was God the Son of God; all but the Pharisees,
who, though the signs shone brighter than the sun, yet complained
still, as ignorant men, ‘Why dost Thou, being a man, make Thyself God Ib. x. 33.?’ Insensate, and verily blind in
understanding! they ought contrariwise to have said, “Why hast
Thou, being God, become man?” for His works proved Him God, that
they might both worship the goodness of the Father, and admire the
Son’s Economy for our sakes. However, this they did not say; no,
nor liked to witness what He was doing; or they witnessed indeed, for
this they could not help, but they changed their ground of complaint
again, “Why healest Thou the paralytic, why makest Thou the
born-blind to see, on the sabbath day?” But this too was an
excuse, and mere murmuring; for on other days as well did the Lord heal
‘all manner of sickness, and all manner of disease Matt. iv. 23.,’ but they complained still according
to their wont, and by calling Him Beelzebub, preferred the suspicion of
Atheism Or
ungodliness, ἀθεότητος. Thus Aetius was called ὁ ἄθεος, the
ungodly. de Synod. §6; and Arius complains that Alexander
had expelled him and his from Alexandria, ὡς ἀνθρώπους
ἀθέους.
Theodor. Hist. i. 4. “Atheism” and
“Atheist” imply intention, system, and profession, and are
so far too strong a rendering of the Greek. Since Christ was God, to
deny Him was to deny God. The force of the term, however, seems to be,
that, whereas the Son had revealed the “unknown God,” and
destroyed the reign of idols, the denial of the Son was bringing back
idolatry and its attendant spiritual ignorance. Thus contr.
Gent. §29. fin. he speaks of “the Greek idolatry as full
of all Atheism” or ungodliness, and contrasts with it the
knowledge of “the Guide and Framer of the Universe, the
Father’s Word,” “that through Him ‘we may
discern His Father,’ and the Greeks may know ‘how far they
have separated themselves from the truth.’” And
Orat. ii. 43. he classes Arians with the Greeks, who
“though they have the name of God in their mouths, incur the
charge of ‘Atheism,’ because they know not the real and
true God, ‘the Father of our Lord Jesus Christ.’”
(vid. also Basil in Eunom. ii. 22.) Shortly afterwards he gives
a further reason for the title, observing that Arianism was worse than
previous heresies, such as Manicheism, inasmuch as the latter denied
the Incarnation, but Arianism tore from God’s substance His
connatural Word, and, as far as its words went, infringed upon the
perfections and being of the first Cause. And so ad Ep. Æg.
§17. fin. he says, that it alone, beyond other heresies,
“has been bold against the Godhead Itself in a mad way
(μανικώτερον, vid. foregoing note), denying that there is a Word, and
that the Father was always Father.” Elsewhere he speaks more
generally, as if Arianism introduced “an Atheism or rather
Judaism ‘against the Scriptures,’ being next door to
Heathenism, so that its disciple cannot be even named Christian; for
all such tenets are ‘contrary to the Scriptures;’”
and he makes this the reason why the Nicene Fathers stopped their ears
and condemned it. ad Ep. Æg. §13. For the same reason
he calls the heathen ἄθεοι, atheistical or
ungodly, “who are arraigned of irreligion by Divine
Scripture.” contr. Gent. §14. vid. εἰδώλων
ἀθεότητα. §46. init. Moreover, he calls the Arian persecution worse
than the pagan ‘cruelties,’ and therefore “a
Babylonian Atheism,” Ep. Encycl. §5. as not allowing
the Catholics the use of prayer and baptism, with a reference to
Dan. vi.
11,
&c. Thus too he calls Constantius atheist, for his treatment of
Hosius; οὔτε
τὸν θεὸν
φοβηθεὶς ὁ
ἄθεος. Hist.
Arian. 45. Another reason for the title seems to have lain in the
idolatrous character of Arian worship ‘on its own shewing,’
viz. as worshipping One whom they yet maintained to be a creature.
[Prolegg. ch. ii. §3 (2)a, sub. fin.], to a recantation of their own wickedness.
And though in such sundry times and divers manners the Saviour shewed
His Godhead and preached the Father to all men, nevertheless, as
kicking against the pricks, they contradicted in the language of folly,
and this they did, according to the divine proverb, that by finding
occasions, they might separate themselves from the truth A
reference to Prov. xviii. 1. which runs in the LXX.
“a man seeketh occasions, when desirous of separating himself
from friends.”.