er462,” a fact which the voice of the Lord never asserted of any conceivable thing in creation,
not of aught visible or invisible, not of thrones, principalities, powers, or dominions, nor of
any other name that is named either in this world or in that which is to come. It is plain
then that that, from share in which all creation is excluded, is something special and peculiar
to uncreated being. But this man bids us believe in “the Guide of godliness.” Let a man then
believe in Paul, and Barnabas, and Titus, and Silvanus, and Timotheus, and all those by
whom we have been led into the way of the faith. For if we are to believe in “that which
guides us to godliness,” along with the Father and the Son, all the prophets and lawgivers
and patriarchs, heralds, evangelists, apostles, pastors, and teachers, have equal honour with
the Holy Spirit, as they have been “guides to godliness” to those who came after them. “Who
came into being,” he goes on, “by the only God through the Only-begotten.” In these words
he gathers up in one head all his blasphemy. Once more he calls the Father “only God,” who
employs the Only-begotten as an instrument for the production of the Spirit. What shadow
of such a notion did he find in Scripture, that he ventures upon this assertion? by deduction
from what premises did he bring his profanity to such a conclusion as this? Which of the
Evangelists says it? what apostle? what prophet? Nay, on the contrary every scripture divinely
inspired, written by the afflatus of the Spirit, attests the Divinity of the Spirit. For example
(for it is better to prove my position from the actual testimonies), those who receive power
to become children of God bear witness to the Divinity of the Spirit. Who knows not that
utterance of the Lord which tells us that they who are born of the Spirit are the children of
God? For thus He expressly ascribes the birth of the children of God to the Spirit, saying,
that as that which is born of the flesh is flesh, so that which is born of the Spirit is spirit. But
as many as are born of the Spirit are called the children of God463. So also when the Lord
by breathing upon His disciples had imparted to them the Holy Spirit, John says, “Of His
fulness have all we received464.” And that “in Him dwelleth the fulness of the Godhead465,”
the mighty Paul attests: yea, moreover, through the prophet Isaiah it is attested, as to the
manifestation of the Divine appearance vouchsafed to him, when he saw Him that sat “on
the throne high and lifted up466;” the older tradition, it is true, says that it was the Father
Who appeared to him, but the evangelist John refers the prophecy to our Lord, saying,
touching those of the Jews who did not believe the words uttered by the prophet concerning
the Lord, “These things said Esaias, when he saw His glory and spoke of Him467.” But the
462 S. John xv. 26
463 With this passage cf. S. John i. 12, iii. 6; Rom. viii. 14; 1 S. John iii. 3.
464 S. John xx. 21, and i. 16.
465 Col. ii. 9.
466 Is. vi. 1.
467 S. John xii. 41. The “older tradition” means presumably the ancient interpretation of the Jews.
248
He proceeds to discuss the views held by Eunomius, and by the Church, touching…