to the true reading of the Creed as adopted by the Second Synod.210 On this point there
never was nor can be any doubt.
2. The addition was not made at the will and at the bidding of the Pope. It has frequently
been said that it was a proof of the insufferable arrogancy of the See of Rome that it dared
to tamper with the creed set forth by the authority of an Ecumenical Synod and which had
been received by the world. Now so far from the history of this addition to the creed being
a ground of pride and complacency to the advocates of the Papal claims, it is a most marked
instance of the weakness of the papal power even in the West.
“Baronius,” says Dr. Pusey, “endeavours in vain to find any Pope, to whom the ‘formal
addition’ may be ascribed, and rests at last on a statement of a writer towards the end of the
12th century, writing against the Greeks. ‘If the Council of Constantinople added to the
Nicene Creed, ‘in the Holy Ghost, the Lord, and Giver of life,’ and the Council of Chalcedon
to that of Constantinople, ‘perfect in Divinity and perfect in Humanity, consubstantial with
the Father as touching his Godhead, consubstantial with us as touching his manhood,’ and
some other things as aforesaid, the Bishop of the elder Rome ought not to be calumniated,
because for explanation, he added one word [that the Holy Spirit proceeds from the Son]
having the consent of very many bishops and most learned Cardinals.’ ‘For the truth of
which,’ says Le Quien, ‘be the author responsible!’ It seems to me inconceivable, that all
account of any such proceeding, if it ever took place, should have been lost.”211
We may then dismiss this point and briefly review the history of the matter.
There seems little doubt that the words were first inserted in Spain. As early as the year
400 it had been found necessary at a Council of Toledo to affirm the double procession
against the Priscillianists,212 and in 589 by the authority of the Third Council of Toledo the
newly converted Goths were required to sign the creed with the addition.213 From this time
it became for Spain the accepted form, and was so recited at the Eighth Council of Toledo
in 653, and again in 681 at the Twelfth Council of Toledo.214
210 In fact the contention of the Latins was that the words were inserted by II. Nice! To this the Easterns
answered most pertinently “Why did you not tell us this long ago?” They were not so fortunate when they insisted
that St. Thomas would have quoted it, for some scholars have thought St. Thomas but ill acquainted with the
proceedings at the Seventh Synod. Vide Hefele, Concil. XLVIII., § 810.
211 E. B. Pusey. On the clause “and The Son,” p. 68.
212 Hefele. Hist. of the Councils, Vol. III., p. 175.
213 Hefele. Hist. Counc., Vol. IV., p. 416.
214 Hefele. Hist. Counc., Vol. IV., p. 470; Vol. V., p. 208.
333
Historical Excursus on the Introduction into the Creed of the Words “and…