5. On their dictating this formula, we did not
let it pass without inquiry in what sense they introduced “of the
essence of the Father,” and “one in essence with the
Father.” Accordingly questions and explanations took place, and
the meaning of the words underwent the scrutiny of reason. And they
professed, that the phrase “of the essence” was indicative
of the Son’s being indeed from the Father, yet without being as
if a part of Him. And with this understanding we thought good to assent
to the sense of such religious doctrine, teaching, as it did, that the
Son was from the Father, not however a part of His essence Eusebius does not commit himself to any positive sense in which
the formula “of the essence” is to be interpreted, but only
says what it does not mean. His comment on it is “of the Father,
but not as a part;” where, what is not negative, instead of being
an explanation, is but a recurrence to the original words of Scripture,
of which ἐξ οὐσίας
itself is the explanation; a curious inversion. Indeed
it is very doubtful whether he admitted the ἐξ
οὐσίας at all.
He says, that the Son is not like the radiance of light so far as this,
that the radiance is an inseparable accident of substance, whereas the
Son is by the Father’s will, κατὰ γνώμην
καὶ
προαίρεσιν, Demonstr. Ev. iv. 3. And though he insists on our
Lord being alone, ἐκ
θεοῦ, yet he means in the
sense which Athan. refutes, supr. §6, viz. that He alone was
created immediately from God, vid. next note 6. It is true that he
plainly condemns with the Nicene Creed the ἐξ
οὐκ ὄντων of the Arians, “out of nothing,” but an evasion was at
hand here also; for he not only adds, according to Arian custom,
“as others” (vid. note following) but he has a theory that
no being whatever is out of nothing, for non-existence cannot be the
cause of existence. God, he says, “proposed His own will and
power as ‘a sort of matter and substance’ of the production
and constitution of the universe, so that it is not reasonably said,
that any thing is out of nothing. For what is from nothing cannot be at
all. How indeed can nothing be to any thing a cause of being? but all
that is, takes its being from One who only is, and was, who also
said ‘I am that I am.’” Demonstr. Ev. iv. 1.
Again, speaking of our Lord, “He who was from nothing would not
truly be Son of God, ‘as neither is any other of things
generate.’” Eccl. Theol. i. 9 fin. [see, however,
D.C.B. ii. p. 347].. On this account we assented to the sense
ourselves, without declining even the term “One in
essence,” peace being the object which we set before us, and
stedfastness in the orthodox view.