Letter LXXXVII.
(a.d. 405.)
To His Brother Emeritus, Beloved and Longed For, Augustin Sends Greeting.
1. I know that it is not on the possession of good talents and a liberal education that the
salvation of the soul depends; but when I hear of any one who is thus endowed holding a
different view from that which truth imperatively insists upon on a point which admits of
very easy examination, the more I wonder at such a man, the more I burn with desire to
make his acquaintance, and to converse with him; or if that be impossible, I long to bring
his mind and mine into contact by exchanging letters, which wing their flight even between
places far apart. As I have heard that you are such a man as I have spoken of, I grieve that
you should be severed and shut out from the Catholic Church, which is spread abroad
throughout the whole world, as was foretold by the Holy Spirit. What your reason for this
separation is I do not know. For it is not disputed that the party of Donatus is wholly un-
known to a great part of the Roman world, not to speak of the barbarian nations (to whom
also the apostle said that he was a debtor2086) whose communion in the Christian faith is
joined with ours, and that in fact they do not even know at all when or upon what account
the dissension began. Now, unless you admit these Christians to be innocent of those crimes
with which you charge the Christians of Africa, you must confess that all of you are defiled
by participation in the wicked actions of all worthless characters, so long as they succeed
(to put the matter mildly) in escaping detection among you. For you do occasionally expel
a member from your communion, in which case his expulsion takes place only after he has
committed the crime for which he merited expulsion. Is there not some intervening time
during which he escapes detection before he is discovered, convicted, and condemned by
you? I ask, therefore, whether he involved you in his defilement so long as he was not dis-
covered by you? You answer, “By no means.” If, then, he were not to be discovered at all,
he would in that case never involve you in his defilement; for it sometimes happens that the
crimes committed by men come to light only after their death, yet this does not bring guilt
upon those Christians who communicated with them while they were alive. Why, then,
have you severed yourselves by so rash and profane schism from the communion of innu-
merable Eastern Churches, in which all that you truly or falsely affirm to have been done
in Africa has been and still is utterly unknown?
366
2. For it is quite another question whether or not there be truth in the assertions made
by you. These assertions we disprove by documents much more worthy of credit than those
which you bring forward, and we further find in your own documents more abundant proof
of those positions which you assail. But this is, as I have said, another question altogether,
to be taken up and discussed when necessary. Meanwhile, let your mind give special attention
2086 Rom. i. 14.
To Emeritus
815
To Emeritus