I suspect that their author
himself would find it difficult to tell us what he meant when he wrote
those words. Their thought is obscured by the rhetorical mud, which is
so thick that one can hardly see beyond any clue to interpret them.
“Their difference amounts to that existing between their
works” is a sentence which might be suspected of coming from some
Loxias of pagan story, mystifying his hearers. But if we may make a
guess at the drift of his observations here by following out those
which we have already examined, this would be his meaning, viz., that
if we know the amount of difference between one work and another, we
shall know the amount of that between the corresponding energies. But
what “works” he here speaks of, it is impossible to
discover from his words. If he means the works to be observed in the
creation, I do not see how this hangs on to what goes before. For the
question was about Father, Son, and Holy Ghost: what occasion was
there, then, for one thinking rationally to inquire one after another
into the nature of earth, and water, and air, and fire, and the
different animals, and to distinguish some works as older and more
honourable than others, and to speak of one energy as transcending
another? But if he calls the Only-begotten and the Holy Spirit
“works,” what does he mean by the “differences”
of the energies which produce these works: and what are κᾀκείναι αἱ
ἐνεργείαι
αὖται.those wonderful energies of this writer which
transcend the others? He has neither explained the particular way in
which he means them to “transcend” each other; nor has he
discussed the nature of these energies: but he has advanced in neither
direction, neither proving so far their real subsistence, nor their
being some unsubstantial exertion of a will. Throughout it all his
meaning hangs suspended between these two conceptions, and oscillates
from one to the other. He adds that “it would be impious to say
that the same energy produced the angels or the stars, and the heavens
or man.” Again we ask what necessity there is to draw this
conclusion from his previous remarks? I do not see that it is proved
any more τῷ
παρηλλάχθαι,
κ.τ.λ. This is Oehler’s
emendation for the faulty reading τὸ of the editions.because the energies vary amongst
themselves as much as the works do, and because the works are not all
from the same source but are stated by him to come from different
sources. As for the heavens and each angel, star, and man, or anything
else understood by the word “creation,” we know from
Scripture that they are all the work of One: whereas in their system of
theology the Son and the Spirit are not the work of one and the same,
the Son being the work of the energy which ‘follows’ the
first Being, and the Spirit the further work of that work. What the
connexion, then, is between that statement and the heavens, man, angel,
star, which he drags in, must be revealed by himself, or some one whom
he has initiated into his profound philosophy. The blasphemy intended
by his words is plain enough, but the way the profanity is stated is inconsistent
with itself. To suppose that within the Holy Trinity there is a
difference as wide as that which we can observe between the heavens
which envelope the whole creation, and one single man or the star which
shines in them, is openly profane: but still the connexion of such
thoughts and the pertinence of such a comparison is a mystery to me,
and I suspect also to its author himself. If indeed his account of the
creation were of this sort, viz., that while the heavens were the work
of some transcendent energy each star in them was the result of an
energy accompanying the heavens, and that then an angel was the result
of that star, and a man of that angel, his argument would then have
consisted in a comparison of similar processes, and might have somewhat
confirmed his doctrine. But since he grants that it was all made by One
(unless he wishes to contradict Scripture downright), while he
describes the production of the Persons after a different fashion, what
connexion is there between this newly imported view and what went
before?