So, after beholding such things as these, I began to inquire whence they arise, and what
is their origin, and who is the author of such devices against men, whence came their discov-
ery, and who is the teacher of them. Now to dare to say that God was the author of these
things was impossible; for surely it could not even be said that they have from Him their
substance, or their existence. For how were it possible to entertain these thoughts of God?
For He is good, and the Creator of what is excellent, and to Him belongs nothing bad. Nay,
it is His nature to take no pleasure in such things; but He forbids their production, and rejects
358
those who delight in them, but admits into His presence those who avoid them. And how
could it be anything but absurd to call God the maker of these things of which He disap-
proves? For He would not wish them not to be, if He had first been their creator; and He
wishes those who approach Him to be imitators of Him.
Wherefore it seemed to me unreasonable to attribute these things to God, or to speak
of them as having sprung from Him; though it must certainly be granted that it is possible
for something to come into existence out of what has no existence, in case He made what
is evil. For He who brought them into existence out of non-existence would not reduce them
to the loss of it. And again, it must be said that there was once a time when God took
pleasure in evil things, which now is not the case. Wherefore it seems to me impossible to
say this of God. For it is unsuitable to His nature to attach this to Him. Wherefore it seemed
to me that there is co-existent with Him somewhat which has the name of matter, from
which He formed existing things, distinguishing between them with wise art, and arranging
them in a fair order, from which also evil things seem to have come into being. For as this
matter was without quality or form, and, besides this, was borne about without order, and
was untouched by divine art, God bore no grudge against it, nor left it to be continually thus
borne about, but began to work upon it, and wished to separate its best parts from its worst,
and thus made all that it was fitting for God to make out of it; but so much of it as was like
lees, so to speak, this being unfitted for being made into anything, He left as it was, since it
was of no use to Him; and from this it seems to me that what is evil has now streamed down
among men. This seemed to me the right view to take of these things. But, my friend, if you
think that anything I have said is wrong, mention it, for I exceedingly desire to hear about
these things.
Orthodoxus. I appreciate your readiness, my friend, and applaud your zeal about the
subject; and as for the opinion which you have expressed respecting existing things, to the
effect that God made them out of some underlying substance, I do not altogether find fault
with it. For, truly, the origin of evil is a subject that has called out opinions from many
men.2835 Before you and me, no doubt, there have been many able men who have made the
2835 [See the essay of Archbishop King On the Origin of Evil, ed. Cambridge, 1739. Law’s annotations in this
edition are valuable. See also Dr. Bledsoe, Theodicy, and Elucidation VIII. p. 522, vol. ii, this series. Of Leibnitz
813
Concerning Free-Will.