Thus far for our statement. But this reviler of all quibblers, who
completely arms his own argument with the truth, and arraigns our sins
in logic, does not blush in any of his arguing on doctrines to indulge
in very pretty quibbles; on a par with those exquisite jokes which are
cracked to make people laugh at dessert. Reflect on the weight of
reasoning displayed in that complicated syllogism; which I will now
again repeat. “If ‘Father’ is the same as Ungenerate,
it is allowable for us to drop it, and use Ungenerate instead; thus,
the Ungenerate is Ungenerate of the Son; for as the Ungenerate is
Father of the Son, so, reversely, the Father is Ungenerate of the
Son.” Well, this is very like another case such as the following.
Suppose some one were to state the right and sound view about Adam;
namely, that it mattered not whether we called him “father of
mankind” or “the first man formed by God” (for both
mean the same thing), and then some one else, belonging to
Eunomius’ school of reasoners, were to pounce upon this
statement, and make the same complication out of it, viz.: If
“first man formed by God” and “father of
mankind” are the same things, it is allowable for us to drop the
word “father” and use “first formed” instead;
and say that Adam was the “first formed,” instead of the
“father,” of Abel; for as the first formed was the father
of a son, so, reversely, that father is the first formed of that son.
If this had been said in a tavern, what laughter and applause would
have broken from the tippling circle over so fine and exquisite a joke!
These are the arguments on which our learned theologian leans; when he
assails our doctrine, he really needs himself a tutor and a stick to
teach him that all the things which are predicated of some one do not
necessarily, in their meaning, have respect to one single object; as is
plain from the aforesaid instance of Abel and Adam. That one and the
same Adam is Abel’s father and also God’s handiwork is a
truth; nevertheless it does not follow that, because he is both, he is
both with respect to Abel. So the designation of the Almighty as Father
has both the special meaning of that word, i.e., the having begotten a
son, and also that of there being no preconceivable cause of the Very
Father; nevertheless it does not follow that when we mention the Son we
must speak of the Ungenerate, instead of the Father, of that Son; nor,
on the other hand, if the absence of beginning remains unexpressed in
reference to the Son, that we must banish from our thoughts about God
that attribute of Ungeneracy. But he discards the usual acceptations,
and like an actor in comedy, makes a joke of the whole subject, and by
dint of the oddity of his quibbles makes the questions of our faith
ridiculous. Again I must repeat his words: “If Father is the same
as Ungenerate, it is allowable for us to drop it, and use Ungenerate
instead; thus, the Ungenerate is Ungenerate of the Son; for as the
Ungenerate is Father of the Son, so, reversely, the Father is
Ungenerate of the Son.” But let us turn the laugh against him, by
reversing his quibble; thus: If Father is not the same as Ungenerate,
the Son of the Father will not be Son of the Ungenerate; for having
relation to the Father only, he will be altogether alien in nature to
that which is other than Father, and does not suit that idea; so that,
if the Father is something other than the Ungenerate, and the title
Father does not comprehend that meaning, the Son, being One, cannot be
distributed between these two relationships, and be at the same time
Son both of the Father and of the Ungenerate; and, as before it was an
acknowledged absurdity to speak of the Deity as Ungenerate of the Son,
so in this converse proposition it will be found an absurdity just as
great to call the Only-begotten Son of the Ungenerate. So that he must
choose one of two things; either the Father is the same as the
Ungenerate (which is necessary in order that the Son of the Father may
be Son of the Ungenerate as well); and then our doctrine has been
ridiculed by him without reason; or, the Father is something different
to the Ungenerate, and the Son of the Father is alienated from all
relationship to the Ungenerate. But then, if it is thus to hold that
the Only-begotten is not the Son of the Ungenerate, logic inevitably
points to a “generated Father;” for that which exists, but
does not exist without generation, must have a generated substance. If,
then, the Father, being according to these men other than Ungenerate,
is therefore generated, where is their much talked of Ungeneracy? Where
is that basis and foundation of their heretical castle-building? The
Ungenerate, which they thought just now that they grasped, has eluded
them, and vanished quite beneath the action of a few barren syllogisms;
their would-be demonstration of the Unlikeness, like a mere
dream about something, slips away at the touch of criticism, and takes
its flight along with this Ungenerate.