would Cæcilianus have suffered at the hands of the Emperor than that which, when they
were defeated, he awarded to them? But truly, if they having accused him had prevailed,
and Cæcilianus and his colleagues had been expelled from their sees, or, through persisting
in their conspiracy, had exposed themselves to severer punishments (for the imperial censure
could not pass unpunished the resistance of persons who had been defeated in the civil
courts), they would then have published as worthy of all praise the Emperor’s wise measures
and anxious care for the good of the Church. But now, because they have themselves lost
their case, being wholly unable to prove the charges which they advanced, if they suffer
anything for their iniquity, they call it persecution; and not only set no bounds to their
wicked violence, but also claim to be honoured as martyrs: as if the Catholic Christian em-
perors were following in their measures against their most obstinate wickedness any other
precedent than the decision of Constantine, to whom they of their own accord appealed as
the accusers of Cæcilianus, and whose authority they so esteemed above that of all the
bishops beyond the sea, that to him rather than to them they referred this ecclesiastical
dispute. To him, again, they protested against the first judgment given against them by the
bishops whom he had appointed to examine the case in Rome, and to him also they appealed
against the second judgment given by the bishops at Arles: yet when at last they were defeated
by his own decision, they remained unchanged in their perversity. I think that even the
devil himself would not have had the assurance to persist in such a cause, if he had been so
often overthrown by the authority of the judge to whom he had of his own will chosen to
appeal.
4. It may be said, however, that these are human tribunals, and that they might have
been cajoled, misguided, or bribed. Why, then, is the Christian world libelled and branded
with the crime laid to the charge of some who are said to have surrendered to persecutors
the sacred books? For surely it was neither possible for the Christian world, nor incumbent
upon it, to do otherwise than believe the judges whom the plaintiffs had chosen, rather than
the plaintiffs against whom these judges pronounced judgments. These judges are responsible
to God for their opinion, whether just or unjust; but what has the Church, diffused
throughout the world, done that it should be deemed necessary for her to be rebaptized by
the Donatists upon no other ground than because, in a case in which she was not able to
decide as to the truth, she has thought herself called upon to believe those who were in a
position to judge it rightly, rather than those who, though defeated in the civil courts, refused
to yield? O weighty indictment against all the nations to which God promised that they
should be blessed in the seed of Abraham, and has now made His promise good! When they
with one voice demand, Why do you wish to rebaptize us? the answer given is, Because you
do not know what men in Africa were guilty of surrendering the sacred books; and being
831
To Festus