48. For if He is Offspring, how call ye Him
creature? for no one says that He begets what He creates, nor calls His
proper offspring creatures; and again, if He is Only-begotten, how
becomes He ‘beginning of the ways?’ for of necessity, if He
was created a beginning of all things, He is no longer alone, as having
those who came into being after Him. For Reuben, when he became a
beginning of the children ἀρχὴ
τέκνων,
Gen. xlix.
3., was not
only-begotten, but in time indeed first, but in nature and relationship
one among those who came after him. Therefore if the Word also is
‘a beginning of the ways,’ He must be such as the ways are,
and the ways must be such as the Word, though in point of time He be
created first of them. For the beginning or initiative of a city is
such as the other parts of the city are, and the members too being
joined to it, make the city whole and one, as the many members of one
body; nor does one part of it make, and another come to be, and is
subject to the former, but all the city equally has its government and
constitution from its maker. If then the Lord is in such sense created
as a ‘beginning’ of all things, it would follow that He and
all other things together make up the unity of the creation, and He
neither differs from all others, though He become the
‘beginning’ of all, nor is He Lord of them, though older in
point of time; but He has the same manner of framing and the same Lord
as the rest. Nay, if He be a creature, as you hold, how can He be
created sole and first at all, so as to be beginning of all? when it is
plain from what has been said, that among the creatures not any is of a
constant Cf.
p. 157, note 7. nature and of prior formation, but
each has its origination with all the rest, however it may excel others
in glory. For as to the separate stars or the great lights, not this
appeared first, and that second, but in one day and by the same
command, they were all called into being. And such was the original
formation of the quadrupeds, and of birds, and fishes, and cattle, and
plants; thus too has the race made
after God’s Image come to be, namely men; for though Adam only
was formed out of earth, yet in him was involved the succession of the
whole race.