XII. Nothing can be certainly concluded concerning the nature of
religious affections, that any are the subjects of, from this, that the outward
manifestations of them, and the relation persons give of them, are very
affecting and pleasing to the truly godly, and such as greatly gain their
charity, and win their hearts.
The true saints have not such a spirit of discerning that they
can certainly determine who are godly, and who are not. For though they know
experimentally what true religion is, in the internal exercises of it; yet
these are what they can neither feel, nor see, in the heart of another.
31
There is nothing in others, that comes within their view, but outward
manifestations and appearances; but the Scripture plainly intimates, that this
way of judging what is in men by outward appearances, is at best uncertain, and
liable to deceit:
1 Sam. 16:7
, "The Lord seeth not as man seeth; for man
looketh on the outward appearance, but the Lord looketh on the heart."
Isa. 11:3
, "He shall not judge after the sight of his eyes, neither
reprove after the hearing of his ears."
32
They commonly are but poor judges, and dangerous counselors in soul cases, who
are quick and peremptory in determining persons' states, vaunting themselves in
their extraordinary faculty of discerning and distinguishing, in these great
affairs; as though all was open and clear to them. They betray one of these
three things: either that they have had but little experience; or are persons
of a weak judgment; or that they have a great degree of pride and
self-confidence, and so ignorance of themselves. Wise and experienced men will
proceed with great caution in such an affair.
When there are many probable appearances of piety in others, it
is the duty of the saints to receive them cordially into their charity, and to
love them and rejoice in them, as their brethren in Christ Jesus. But yet the
best of men may be, when the appearances seem to them exceeding fair and
bright, as entirely to gain their charity, and conquer their hearts. It has
been common thing in the church of God, for such bright professors, that are
received as eminent saints, among the saints, to fall away and come to nothing.
33
And this we need not wonder at, if we consider the things that have been
already observed; what things it has been shown may appear in men who are
altogether graceless. Nothing hinders but that all these things may meet
together in men, and yet they be without a spark of grace in their hearts. They
may have religious affections of many kinds together; they may have a sort of
affection towards God, that bears a great resemblance of dear love to him; and
so a kind of love to the brethren, and great appearances of admiration of God's
perfections and works, and sorrow for sin, and reverence, submission,
self-abasement, gratitude, joy, religious longings, and zeal for religion and the
good of souls. And these affections may come after great awakenings and
convictions of conscience; and there may be great appearances of a work of
humiliation: and counterfeit love and joy, and other affections may seem to
follow these, and one another, just in the same order that is commonly
observable in the holy affections of true converts. And these religious
affections may be carried to a great height, and may cause abundance of tears,
yea, may overcome the nature of those who are the subjects of them, and may
make them affectionate, and fervent, and fluent, in speaking of the things of
God, and dispose them to be abundant in it; and may be attended with many sweet
texts of Scripture, and precious promises, brought with great impression on
their minds; and may dispose them with their mouths to praise and glorify God,
in a very ardent manner, and fervently to call upon others to praise him,
crying out of their unworthiness, and extolling free grace. And may, moreover,
dispose them to abound in the external duties of religion, such as prayer,
hearing the word preached, singing, and religious conference; and these things
attended with a great resemblance of a Christian assurance, in its greatest
height, when the saints mount on eagles' wings, above all darkness and
doubting. I think it has been made plain, that there may be all these things,
and yet there be nothing more than the common influences of the Spirit of God,
joined with the delusions of Satan, and the wicked and deceitful heart.—To
which I may add, that all these things may be attended with a sweet natural
temper, and a good doctrinal knowledge of religion, and a long acquaintance
with the saints' way of talking, and of expressing their affections and
experiences, and a natural ability and subtlety in accommodating their
expressions and manner of speaking to the dispositions and notions of the
hearers, and a taking decency of expression and behavior, formed by a good
education. How great therefore may the resemblance be, as to all outward
expressions and appearances, between a hypocrite and a true saint! Doubtless it
is the glorious prerogative of the omniscient God, as the great searcher of
hearts, to be able well to separate between sheep and goats. And what an
indecent self-exaltation and arrogance it is, in poor, fallible, dark mortals,
to pretend that they can determine and know, who are really sincere and upright
before God, and who are not!
Many seem to lay great weight on that, and to suppose it to be
what may determine them with respect to others' real piety, when they not only
tell a plausible story, but when, in giving an account of their experiences,
they make such a representation, and speak after such a manner, that they feel
their talk; that is to say, when their talk seems to harmonize with their own
experience, and their hearts are touched and affected and delighted, by what
they hear them say, and drawn out by it, in dear love to them. But there is not
that certainty in such things, and that full dependence to be had upon them,
which many imagine. A true saint greatly delights in holiness; it is a most
beautiful thing in his eyes; and God's work, in savingly renewing and making
holy and happy, a poor, and before perishing soul, appears to him a most
glorious work: no wonder, therefore, that his heart is touched, and greatly
affected, when he hears another give a probable account of this work, wrought
on his own heart, and when he sees in him probable appearances of holiness;
whether those pleasing appearances have anything real to answer them, or no.
And if he uses the same words, which are commonly made use of, to express the
affections of true saints, and tells of many things following one another in an
order, agreeable to the method of the experience of him that hears him, and
also speaks freely and boldly, and with an air of assurance; no wonder the
other thinks his experiences harmonize with his own. And if, besides all this,
in giving his relation, he speaks with much affection; and, above all, if in
speaking he seems to show much affection to him to whom he speaks, such an
affection as the Galatians did to the Apostle Paul; these things will naturally
have a powerful influence, to affect and draw his hearer's heart, and open wide
the doors of his charity towards him. David speaks as one who had felt
Ahithophel's talk, and had once a sweet savor and relish of it. And therefore
exceeding great was his surprise and disappointment, when he fell; it was
almost too much for him:
Psal. 55:12, 13, 14
, "It was not an enemy—then I
could have borne it; but it was thou, a man, mine equal, my guide, and mine
acquaintance: we took sweet counsel together, and walked unto the house of God
in company."
It is with professors of religion, especially such as become so
in a time of outpouring of the Spirit of God, as it is with blossoms in the
spring;
34
there are vast numbers of them upon the trees, which all look fair and
promising; but yet many of them never come to anything. And many of those, that
in a little time wither up, and drop off, and rot under the trees; yet for a
while look as beautiful and gay as others; and not only so, but smell sweet,
and send forth a pleasant odor; so that we cannot, by any of our senses,
certainly distinguish those blossoms which have in them that secret virtue,
which will afterwards appear in the fruit, and that inward solidity and
strength which shall enable them to bear, and cause them to be perfected by the
hot summer sun, that will dry up the others. It is the mature fruit which comes
afterwards, and not the beautiful colors and smell of the blossoms, that we
must judge by. So new converts (professedly so), in their talk about things of
religion, may appear fair, and be very savory, and the saints may think they
talk feelingly. They may relish their talk, and imagine they perceive a divine
savor in it, and yet all may come to nothing.
It is strange how hardly men are brought to be contented with the
rules and directions Christ has given them, but they must needs go by other
rules of their counsels which Christ ever delivered more plainly, than the
rule. I know of no directions or councils which Christ ever delivered more
plainly, than the rule he has given us, to guide our judging of others'
sincerity, viz., that we should judge of the tree chiefly by the fruit: but yet
this will not do; but other ways are found out, which are imagined to be more
distinguishing and certain. And woeful have been the mischievous consequences
of this arrogant setting up men's wisdom above the wisdom of Christ. I believe
many saints have gone much out of the way of Christ's word, in this respect:
and some of them have been chastised with whips, and (I had almost said)
scorpions, to bring them back again. But many things which have lately
appeared, and do now appear, may convince that ordinarily those who have gone
farthest this way, that have been most highly conceited of their faculty of
discerning, and have appeared most forward, peremptorily and suddenly to
determine the state of men's souls, have been hypocrites, who have known
nothing of true religion.
In the parable of the wheat and tares, it is said,
Matt. 13:26
,
"When the blade was sprung up, and brought forth fruit, then appeared the
tares also." As though the tares were not discerned, nor distinguishable from
the wheat, until then, as Mr. Flavel observes,
35
who mentions it as an observation of Jerome's, that "wheat and tares are
so much alike, until the blade of the wheat comes to bring forth the ear, that
it is next to impossible to distinguish them." And then Mr. Flavel adds,
"How difficult soever it be to discern the difference between wheat and
tares; yet doubtless the eye of sense can much easier discriminate them, than
the most quick and piercing eye of man can discern the difference between
special and common grace. For all saving graces in the saints, have their
counterfeits in hypocrites; there are similar works in those, which a spiritual
and very judicious eye may easily mistake for the saving and genuine effects of
a sanctifying spirit."
As it is the ear of the fruit which distinguishes the wheat from
the tares, so this is the true Shibboleth, that he who stands as judge at the
passages of Jordan, makes use of to distinguish those that shall pass over
Jordan into the true Canaan, from those that should be slain at the passages.
For the Hebrew word Shibboleth signifies an ear of corn. And perhaps the more
full pronunciation of Jephthah's friends, Shibboleth, may represent a full ear
with fruit in it, typifying the fruits of the friends of Christ, the antitype
of Jephthah; and the more lean pronunciation of the Ephraimites, his enemies,
may represent their empty ears, typifying the show of religion in hypocrites,
without substance and fruit. This is agreeable to the doctrine we are
abundantly taught in Scripture, viz., that he who is set to judge those that
pass through death, whether they have a right to enter into the heavenly Canaan
or no, or whether they should not be slain, will judge every man according to
his works.
We seem to be taught the same things, by the rules given for the
priest's discerning the leprosy. In many cases it was impossible for the priest
to determine whether a man had the leprosy, or whether he were clean, by the
most narrow inspection of the appearances that were upon him, until he had
waited to see what the appearances would come to, and had shut up the person
who showed himself to him, one seven days after another; and when he judged, he
was to determine by the hair, which grew out of the spot that was showed him,
which was as it were the fruit that it brought forth.
And here, before I finish what I have to say under this head, I
would say something to a strange notion some have of late been led away with,
of certainly knowing the good estate that others are in, as though it were
immediately revealed to them from heaven, by their love flowing out to them in
an extraordinary manner. They argue thus, that their love being very sensible
and great, it may be certainly known by them who feel it, to be a true
Christian love: and if it be a true Christian love, the Spirit of God must be
the author of it: and inasmuch as the Spirit of God who knows certainly,
whether others are the children of God or no, and is a spirit of truth, is
pleased by an uncommon influence upon them, to cause their love to flow out, in
an extraordinary manner, towards such a person as a child of God; it must needs
be, that this infallible Spirit, who deceives none, knows that that person is a
child of God. But such persons might be convinced of the falseness of their
reasoning, if they would consider whether or no it be not their duty, and what
God requires of them, to love those as the children of God who they think are
the children of God, and whom they have no reason to think otherwise of, from
all that they can see in them, though God, who searches the hearts, knows them
not to be his children.
If it be their duty, then it is good, and the want of it sin; and
therefore surely the Spirit of God may be the author of it: the Spirit of God,
without being a spirit of falsehood, may in such a case assist a person to do
his duty, and keep him from sin. But then they argue from the uncommon degree
and special manner, in which their love flows out to the person, which they
think the Spirit of God never would cause, if he did not know the object to be
a child of God. But then I would ask them, whether or no it is not their duty
to love all such as they are bound to think are the children of God, from all
that they can see in them, to a very great degree, though God, from other
things which he sees, that are out of sight to them, knows them not to be so.
It is men's duty to love all whom they are bound in charity to look upon as the
children of God, with a vastly dearer affection than they commonly do. As we
ought to love Christ to the utmost capacity of our nature, so it is our duty to
love those who we think are so near and dear to him as his members, with an
exceeding dear affection, as Christ has loved us; and therefore it is sin in us
not to love them so. We ought to pray to God that he would by his Spirit keep
us from sin, and enable us to do our duty: and may not his Spirit answer our
prayers, and enable us to do our duty, in a particular instance, without lying?
If he cannot, then the Spirit of God is bound not to help his people to do
their duty in some instances, because he cannot do it without being a spirit of
falsehood. But surely God is so sovereign as that comes to, that he may enable
us to do our duty when he pleases, and on what occasion he pleases. When
persons think others are his children, God may have other ends in causing their
exceedingly endeared love to flow out to them, besides revealing to them
whether their opinion of them be right or no: he may have that merciful end in
it to enable them to know their duty, and to keep them from that dreadful
infinite evil, sin. And will they say God shall not show them that mercy in
such a case? If I am at a distance from home, and hear, that in my absence my
house is burnt, but my family have, in some extraordinary manner, all escaped
the flames; and everything in the circumstances of the story, as I hear it,
makes it appear very credible, it would be sin in me, in such a case, not to
feel a very great degree of gratitude to God, though the story indeed be not
true. And is not God so sovereign, that he may, if he pleases, show me that
mercy on that occasion, and enable me to do my duty in a much further degree
than I used to do it, and yet not incur the charge of deceitfulness in confirming
a falsehood?
It is exceeding manifest, that error or mistake may be the
occasion of a gracious exercise, and consequently a gracious influence of the
Spirit of God by
Rom. 14:6
: "He that eateth to the Lord he eateth, and
giveth God thanks; and he that eateth not to the Lord he eateth not, and giveth
God thanks!" The apostle is speaking of those, who through erroneous and
needless scruples, avoided eating legally unclean meats.—By this it is very
evident, that there may be true exercises of grace, a true respect to the Lord,
and particularly, a true thankfulness, which may be occasioned, both by an
erroneous judgment and practice. And consequently, an error may be the occasion
of those true holy exercises that are from the infallible Spirit of God. And if
so, it is certainly too much for us to determine, to how great a degree the
Spirit of God may give this holy exercise, on such an occasion.
This notion, of certainly discerning another's state, by love
flowing out, is not only not founded on reason or Scripture, but it is
anti-scriptural, it is against the rules of Scripture; which say not a word of
any such way of judging the state of others as this, but direct us to judge
chiefly by the fruits that are seen in them. And it is against the doctrines of
Scripture, which do plainly teach us, that the state of others' souls towards
God cannot be known by us, as in
Rev. 2:17
: "To him that overcometh will I
give to eat of the hidden manna, and I will give him a white stone, and in the
stone a new name written, which no man knoweth, saving he that receiveth
it." And
Rom. 2:29
, "He is a Jew, which is one inwardly; and
circumcision is that of the heart, in the spirit, and not in the letter, whose
praise is not of men, but of God." That by this last expression,
"whose praise is not of men, but of God," the apostle has respect to
the insufficiency of men to judge concerning him, whether he be inwardly a Jew
or no (as they could easily see by outward marks, whether men were outwardly
Jews), and would signify, that it belongs to God alone to give a determining
voice in this matter, is confirmed by the same apostle's use of the phrase, in
1 Cor. 4:5
: "Therefore judge nothing before the time, until the Lord come,
who both will bring to light the hidden things of darkness, and will make
manifest the counsels of the heart:" and then shall every man have praise
of God. The apostle, in the two foregoing verses, says, "But with me it is
a very small thing that I should be judged of you, or of man's judgment: yea, I
judge not mine own self. For I know nothing by myself, yet am I not hereby
justified; but he that judgeth me is the Lord." And again, it is further
confirmed, because the apostle, in this second chapter to the Romans, directs
his speech especially to those who had a high conceit of their own holiness,
made their boast of God, and were confident of their own discerning, and that
they knew God's will, and approved the things which were excellent, or tried
the things that differ (as it is in the margin), ver. 19: "And were
confident that they were guides of the blind, and a light to them which are in
darkness, instructors of the foolish, teachers of babes; and so took upon them
to judge others." See ver. 1, and 17, 18, 19, 20.
And how arrogant must the notion be, that they have, who imagine
they can certainly know others' godliness, when that great Apostle Peter
pretends not to say any more concerning Sylvanus, than that he was a faithful
brother, as he supposed!
1 Pet. 5:12
. Though this Sylvanus appears to have been
a very eminent minister of Christ, and an evangelist, and a famous light in
God's church at that day, and an intimate companion of the apostles. See
2 Cor.
1:19, 1
Thess. 1:1, and
2 Thess. 1:1
.
31
Men
may have the knowledge of their own conversion: the knowledge that other men
have of it is uncertain, because no man can look into the heart of another and
see the workings of grace there."
Stoddard's Nature of Saving
Conversion,
chap. 15 at the beginning.
32
Mr.
Stoddard observes, that "all visible signs are common to converted and
unconverted men; and a relation of experiences, among the rest."
Appeal
to the Learned
, p. 75.
"O
how hard it is for the eye of man to discern betwixt chaff and wheat! And how
many upright hearts are now censured, whom God will clear! How many false
hearts are now approved whom God will condemn! Men ordinarily have no
convictive proofs, but only probable symptoms; which at most beget but a
conjectural knowledge of another's state. And they that shall peremptorily
judge either way, may possibly wrong the generation of the upright, or on the
other side, absolve and justify the wicked. And truly, considering what has
been said, it is no wonder that dangerous mistakes are so frequently made in
this matter."
Flavel's Husbandry Spiritualized,
chap. 12.
33
"Be
not offended, if you see great cedars fall, stars fall from heaven, great
professors die and decay: do not think they be all such: do not think that the
elect shall fall. Truly, some are such that when they fall, one would think a
man truly sanctified might fall away, as the Arminians think:
1 John 2:19
,
They
were not of us
. I speak this, because the Lord is shaking; and I look for
great apostasies: for God is trying all his friends, through all the Christian
world. In Germany what profession was there! Who would have thought it? The
Lord, who delights to manifest that openly, which was hid secretly, ends a
sword and they fall."
Shepard's Parab
. Part 1. p. 118, 119.
"The
saints may approve thee and God condemn thee.
Rev. 3:1
, "Thou hast a name
that thou livest, and art dead." Men may say, There is a true Nathanael,
and God may say, There is a self-cozening Pharisee. Reader, thou hast heard of
Judas and Demas, of Ananias and Sapphira, of Hymeneus and Philetus, once
renowned and famous professors, and thou hast heard how they proved at
last."
Flavel's Touchstone of Sincerity
, Chap. 2. Sect. 5.
34
A
time of outpouring of the Spirit of God, reviving religion, and producing the
pleasant appearances of it, in new converts, is in Scripture compared to this
very thing, viz., the spring season, when the benign influences of the heavens
cause the blossoms to put forth.
Cant. 2:11, 12
.
35
Husbandry
Spiritualized, Chap. 12.