Every essayist and every pamphleteer will have you, most Excellent, to
display his eloquence upon; your wondrous qualities will be a broad
race-course wherein he may expatiate. A noble and suggestive subject in
able hands has indeed a way of making a grander style, lifting it to
the height of the great reality. We, however, like an aged horse, will
remain outside this proposed race-course, only turning the ear to
listen for the contest waged in celebrating your praises, if the sound
of any literary car careering in full swing through such wonders may
reach us. But though old age may compel a horse to remain away from the
race, it may often happen that the din of the trampling racers rouses
him into excitement, that he lifts his head with eager looks, that he
shows his spirit in his breathings, and prances and paws the ground
frequently, though this eagerness is all that is left to him, and time
has sapped his powers of going. In the same way our pen remains outside
the combat, and age compels it to yield the course to the professors
who flourish now; nevertheless its eagerness to join the contest about
you survives, and that it can still evince, even though these stylists
who flourish now are at the height of their powers εἴπερ
ἡβῶσιν οἱ
κατὰ τοὺς νῦν
τοῖς λόγοις
ἀκμάζοντες. The Latin translator Laurent. Sifanus, I. U. Doct.
(Basle, 1562), must have had a different text to this of the Paris
Edit.: “si quidem ita floreret ut qui nunc eloquentiâ
vigent.”. But none of this display of my enthusiasm
for you has anything to do with sounding your own praises: no style,
however nervous and well-balanced, would easily succeed there; so that
any one, who attempted to describe that embarrassing yet harmonious
mixture of opposites in your character, would inevitably be left far
behind your real worth. Nature, indeed, by throwing out the shade of
the eyelashes before the glaring rays, brings to the eyes themselves a
weaker light, and so the sunlight becomes tolerable to us, mingling as
it does, in quantities proportionate to our need, with the shadows
which the lashes cast. Just so the grandeur and the greatness of your
character, tempered by your modesty and humbleness of mind, instead of
blinding the beholder’s eye, makes the sight on the contrary a
pleasurable one; wherein this humbleness of mind does not occasion the
splendour of the greatness to be dimmed, and its latent force to be
overlooked; but the one is to be noticed in the other, the humility of
your character in its elevation, and the grandeur reversely in the
lowliness. Others must describe all this; and extol, besides, the
many-sightedness of your mind. Your intellectual eyes are indeed as
numerous, it may perhaps be said, as the hairs of the head; their keen
unerring gaze is on everything alike; the distant is foreseen; the near
is not unnoticed; they do not wait for experience to teach expedience;
they see with Hope’s insight, or else with that of Memory; they
scan the present all over; first on one thing, then on another, but
without confusing them, your mind works with the same energy and with
the amount of attention that is required. Another, too, must record his
admiration of the way in which poverty is made rich by you; if indeed
any one is to be found in this age of ours who will make that a
subject of praise and wonder. Yet surely now, if never before, the love
of poverty will through you abound, and your ingotten wealth πλινθότης, playing upon πλίνθων just above; a word seemingly peculiar to Gregory. We cannot help
thinking here of Plato’s definition of the good man, τετράγωνος
ἄνευ ψόγου: though the idea here is that of richness rather than
shape. will be envied above the ingots of
Crœsus. For whom has sea and land, with all the dower of their
natural produce, enriched, as thy rejection of worldly abundance has
enriched thee? They wipe the stain from steel and so make it shine like
silver: so has the gleam of thy life grown brighter, ever carefully
cleansed from the rust of wealth. We leave that to those who can
enlarge upon it, and also upon your excellent knowledge of the things
in which it is more glorious to gain than to abstain from gain. Grant
me, however, leave to say, that you do not despise all acquisitions;
that there are some which, though none of your predecessors has been
able to clutch, yet you and you alone have seized with both your hands;
for, instead of dresses and slaves and money, you have and hold the
very souls of men, and store them in the treasure-house of your love.
The essayists and pamphleteers, whose glory comes from such laudations,
will go into these matters. But our pen, veteran as it now is, is to
rouse itself only so far as to go at a foot’s pace through the
problem which your wisdom has proposed; namely, this—what we are
to think of those who are taken prematurely, the moment of whose birth
almost coincides with that of their death. The cultured heathen Plato
spoke, in the person of one who had come to life again i.e.Er the Armenian. See Plato,
Repub. x. §614, &c., much philosophy about the judgment courts
in that other world; but he has left this other question a mystery, as
ostensibly too great for human conjecture to be employed upon. If,
then, there is anything in these lucubrations of ours that is of a
nature to clear up the obscurities of this question, you will doubtless
welcome the new account of it; if otherwise, you will at all events
excuse this in old age, and accept, if nothing else, our wish to afford
you some degree of pleasure. History An
anecdote resembling what follows, but not quite the same, is told of
Xerxes in Ælian’s Var. Hist. xii. 40. Erasmus also
refers to it in his Adagia. says that
Xerxes, that great prince who had made almost every land under the sun
into one vast camp, and roused with his own designs the whole world,
when he was marching against the Greeks received with delight a poor
man’s gift; and that gift was water, and that not in a jar, but
carried in the hollow of the palm of his hand. So do you, of your
innate generosity, follow his example; to him the will made the gift,
and our gift may be found in itself but a poor watery thing. In the
case of the wonders in the heavens, a man sees their beauty
equally, whether he is trained to watch them, or whether he gazes
upwards with an unscientific eye; but the feeling towards them
is not the same in the man who comes from philosophy to their
contemplation, and in him who has only his senses of perception to
commit them to; the latter may be pleased with the sunlight, or deem
the beauty of stars worthy of his wonder, or have watched the stages of
the moon’s course throughout the month; but the former, who has
the soul-insight, and whose training has enlightened him so as to
comprehend the phenomena of the heavens, leaves unnoticed all these
things which delight the senses of the more unthinking, and looks at
the harmony of the whole, inspecting the concert which results even
from opposite movements in the circular revolutions; how the inner
circles of these turn the contrary way to that in which the fixed stars
are carried round τῇ ἀπλανεῖ
περιφορᾷ. This is of course the Ptolemaic system which had already been in
vogue two centuries. Sun, and moon, and all, were “planets”
round the earth as a centre: until the 8th sphere, in which the stars
were fixed, was reached; and above this was the crystalline sphere,
under the primum mobile. Cf. Milton, Par. Lost, iii. 481:
“They pass the planets seven, and pass the
fix’d:” and see note p. 257.; how those of the
heavenly bodies to be observed in these inner circles are variously
grouped in their approachments and divergements, their disappearances
behind each other and their flank movements, and yet effect always
precisely in the same way that notable and never-ending harmony; of
which those are conscious who do not overlook the position of the
tiniest star, and whose minds, by training domiciled above, pay equal
attention to them all. In the same way do you, a precious life to me,
watch the Divine economy; leaving those objects which unceasingly
occupy the minds of the crowd, wealth, I mean, and luxury Reading τρυφὴν. The
Paris Edit. has τύφον. and vainglory—things which like
sunbeams flashing in their faces dazzle the unthinking—you will
not pass without inquiry the seemingly most trivial questions in the
world; for you do most carefully scrutinize the inequalities in human
lives; not only with regard to wealth and penury, and the differences
of position and descent (for you know that they are as nothing, and
that they owe their existence not to any intrinsic reality, but to the
foolish estimate of those who are struck with nonentities, as if they
were actual things; and that if one were only to abstract from somebody
who glitters with glory the blind adoration τὴν
μύησιν. of
those who gaze at him, nothing would be left him after all the inflated
pride which elates him, even though the whole mass of the world’s
riches were buried in his cellars), but it is one of your anxieties to
know, amongst the other intentions of each detail of the Divine
government, wherefore it is that, while the life of one is lengthened
into old age, another has only so far a portion of it as to breathe the
air with one gasp, and die. If nothing in this world happens without
God, but all is linked to the Divine will, and if the Deity is skilful
and prudential, then it follows necessarily that there is some plan in
these things bearing the mark of His wisdom, and at the same time of
His providential care. A blind unmeaning occurrence can never be the
work of God; for it is the property of God, as the Scripture says Ps. civ. 24., to “make all things in wisdom.”
What wisdom, then, can we trace in the following? A human being enters
on the scene of life, draws in the air, beginning the process of living
with a cry of pain, pays the tribute of a tear to Nature ἐλειτούργησε
τὸ δάκρυον, just tastes life’s sorrows, before
any of its sweets have been his, before his feelings have gained
any strength;
still loose in all his joints, tender, pulpy, unset; in a word, before
he is even human (if the gift of reason is man’s peculiarity, and
he has never had it in him), such an one, with no advantage over the
embryo in the womb except that he has seen the air, so short-lived,
dies and goes to pieces again; being either exposed or suffocated, or
else of his own accord ceasing to live from weakness. What are we to
think about him? How are we to feel about such deaths? Will a soul such
as that behold its Judge? Will it stand with the rest before the
tribunal? Will it undergo its trial for deeds done in life? Will it
receive the just recompense by being purged, according to the Gospel
utterances, in fire, or refreshed with the dew of blessing There
is introduced at these words in the text of the Paris Edition the
following “Explicatio,” in Greek. “Here it is
manifest that the father means by the ‘purging fire’ the
torments and agonies suffered by those who having sinned have not
completed a worthy and adequate repentance, according to the Gospel
parable of the Rich Man and Lazarus. For it is clear that he is
thinking of this parable when he says, ‘either purged in
fire’ (i.e. the Rich Man), ‘or refreshed with the
dew of blessing’ (i.e. Lazarus). But that sentence of the
Judgment, ‘They shall go, these into everlasting punishment, but
the just into life everlasting,’ has no place as yet in
these sufferings.” In other words, the commentator sees here the
doctrine of Purgatory, as held by the Roman Church. And when we compare
the other passages in Gregory about the “cleansing fire,”
especially that De Animâ et Resurrectione,
247 B, we shall see that he contemplates the judgment (“the
incorruptible tribunal”) as coming not only after the
Resurrection, but also after the chastising process. Not till the
Judgment will the moral value of each life be revealed; the
chastising is a purely natural process. But then the belief in a
Judgment coming after everything rather contradicts the Universalism
with which he has been charged, for what necessity would there be for
it, if the chastising was successful in every instance? With regard to
the nature of this “fire,” it is spiritual or material with
him according to the context. The invisible natures will be punished
with the one, the visible (i.e. the World) with the other:
although this destruction is not always preserved by him. See E.
Moeller (on Gregory’s Doctrine on Human Nature), p.
100.? But I do not see how we can imagine that,
in the case of such a soul. The word “retribution” implies
that something must have been previously given; but he who has not
lived at all has been deprived of the material from which to give
anything. There being, then, no retribution, there is neither good nor
evil left to expect. “Retribution” purports to be the
paying back of one of these two qualities; but that which is to be
found neither in the category of good nor that of bad is in no category
at all; for this antithesis between good and bad is an opposition that
admits no middle; and neither will come to him who has not made a
beginning with either of them. What therefore falls under neither of
these heads may be said not even to have existed. But if some one says
that such a life does not only exist, but exists as one of the good
ones, and that God gives, though He does not repay, what is good to
such, we may ask what sort of reason he advances for this partiality;
how is justice apparent in such a view; how will he prove his idea in
concordance with the utterances in the Gospels? There (the Master)
says, the acquisition of the Kingdom comes to those who are deemed
worthy of it, as a matter of exchange. “When ye have done such
and such things, then it is right that ye get the Kingdom as a
reward.” But in this case there is no act of doing or of willing
beforehand, and so what occasion is there for saying that these will
receive from God any expected recompense? If one unreservedly accepts a
statement such as that, to the effect that any so passing into life
will necessarily be classed amongst the good, it will dawn upon him
then that not partaking in life at all will be a happier state than
living, seeing that in the one case the enjoyment of good is placed
beyond a doubt even with barbarian parentage, or a conception from a
union not legitimate; but he who has lived the span ordinarily possible
to Nature gets the pollution of evil necessarily mingled more or less
with his life, or, if he is to be quite outside this contagion, it will
be at the price of much painful effort. For virtue is achieved by its
seekers not without a struggle; nor is abstinence from the paths of
pleasure a painless process to human nature. So that one of two
probations must be the inevitable fate of him who has had the longer
lease of life; either to combat here on Virtue’s toilsome field,
or to suffer there the painful recompense of a life of evil. But in the
case of infants prematurely dying there is nothing of that sort; but
they pass to the blessed lot at once, if those who take this view of
the matter speak true. It follows also necessarily from this that a
state of unreason is preferable to having reason, and virtue will
thereby be revealed as of no value: if he who has never possessed it
suffers no loss, so, as regards the enjoyment of blessedness, the
labour to acquire it will be useless folly; the unthinking condition
will be the one that comes out best from God’s judgment. For
these and such-like reasons you bid me sift the matter, with a view to
our getting, by dint of a closely-reasoned inquiry, some firm ground on
which to rest our thoughts about it.