Bishop Bull has suggested a very ingenious
interpretation of it, which is not obvious, but which, when stated, has
much plausibility, as going to explain, or rather to sanction, certain
modes of speech in some early Fathers of venerable authority, which
have been urged by heterodox writers, and given up by Catholics of the
Roman School, as savouring of Arianism. The foregoing pages have made
it abundantly evident that the point of controversy between Catholics
and Arians was, not whether our Lord was God, but whether He was Son of
God; the solution of the former question being involved in that of the
latter. The Arians maintained that the very word ‘Son’
implied a ‘beginning,’ or that our Lord was not Very God;
the Catholics said that it implied ‘connaturality,’ or that
He was Very God as one with God. Now five early writers, Athenagoras,
Tatian, Theophilus, Hippolytus, and Novatian, of whom the authority of
Hippolytus is very great, not to speak of Theophilus and Athenagoras,
whatever be thought of Tatian and of Novatian, seem to speak of the
divine generation as taking place immediately before the creation of
the world, that is, as if not eternal, though at the same time they teach that our Lord
existed before that generation. In other words they seem to teach that
He was the Word from eternity, and became the Son at the beginning of
all things; some of them expressly considering Him, first as the λόγος
ἐνδιάθετος,
or Reason, in the Father, or (as may be speciously represented) a mere
attribute; next, as the λόγος
προφορικὸς,
or Word, terms which are explained, note on de Syn. 26 (5). This
doctrine, when divested of figure and put into literal statement, might
appear nothing more or less than this,—that at the beginning of
the world the Son was created after the likeness of the Divine
attribute of Reason, as its image or expression, and thereby became the
Divine Word, was made the instrument of creation, called the Son from
that ineffable favour and adoption which God had bestowed on Him, and
in due time sent into the world to manifest God’s perfections to
mankind;—which, it is scarcely necessary to say, is the doctrine
of Arianism.