81. Your letter on the meaning of ὁμοούσιον and
ὁμοιούσιον,
which Valens, Ursacius and Germinius demanded should be read at
Sirmium, I understand to have been on certain points no less cautious
than outspoken. And with regard to ὁμοούσιον and
ὁμοιούσιον
your proof has left no difficulty untouched. As to the latter,
which implies the similarity of essence, our opinions are the
same. But in dealing with the ὁμοούσιον, or the
one essence, you declared that it ought to be rejected because the use
of this word led to the idea that there was a prior substance which two
Persons had divided between themselves. I see the flaw in that
way of taking it. Any such sense is profane, and must be rejected
by the Church’s common decision. The second reason that you
added was that our fathers, when Paul of Samosata was pronounced a
heretic, also rejected the word ὁμοούσιον, on the
ground that by attributing this title to God he had taught that He was
single and undifferentiated, and at once Father and to Himself.
Wherefore the Church still regards it as most profane to exclude the
different personal qualities, and, under the mask of the aforesaid expressions, to revive the
error of confounding the Persons and denying the personal distinctions
in the Godhead. Thirdly you mentioned this reason for
disapproving of the ὁμοούσιον that in
the Council of Nicæa our fathers were compelled to adopt the word
on account of those who said the Son was a creature: although it
ought not to be accepted, because it is not to be found in
Scripture. Your saying this causes me some astonishment.
For if the word ὁμοούσιον must be
repudiated on account of its novelty, I am afraid that the word
ὁμοιούσιον
which is equally absent in Scripture, is in some danger.