arguments and conclusions to this effect, in order to be made good, must depend on such
a supposition as this;—that God’s dispensations of grace, are rectifications or amendments
of his foregoing constitutions and proceedings, which were merely legal; as though the dis-
pensations of grace, which succeed those of mere law, implied an acknowledgment, that the
preceding legal constitution would be unjust, if left as it was, or at least very hard dealing
with mankind; and that the other were of the nature of a satisfaction to his creatures, for
former injuries, or hard treatment. So that, put together the injury with the satisfaction, the
legal and injurious dispensation, taken with the following good dispensation, which our
author calls grace, and the unfairness or improper severity of the former, amended by the
goodness of the latter, both together made up one righteous dispensation.
The reader is desired to bear in mind what I have said concerning the interposition of
divine grace not altering the nature of things, as they are in themselves. Accordingly, when
I speak of such and such an evil tendency of things, belonging to the present nature and state
148
of mankind, understand me to mean their tendency as they are in themselves, abstracted
from any consideration of that remedy the sovereign and infinite grace of God has
provided.—Having premised these things, I now assert, that mankind are all naturally in
such a state, as is attended, without fail, with this consequence or issue; that they universally
run themselves into that which is, in effect, their own utter eternal perdition, as being finally
accursed of God, and the subjects of his remediless wrath through sin.—From which I infer,
that the natural state of the mind of man is attended with a propensity of nature, which is
prevalent and effectual, to such an issue; and that therefore their nature is corrupt and de-
praved with a moral depravity, that amounts to and implies their utter undoing.
Here I would first consider the truth of the proposition; and then would show the cer-
tainty of the consequences which I infer from it. If both can be clearly and certainly proved,
then I trust, none will deny but that the doctrine of original depravity is evident, and so the
falseness of Dr. T.’s scheme demonstrated; the greatest part of whose book, called the
Scripture Doctrine of Original Sin, &c. is against the doctrine of innate depravity. In p. 107.
S. he speaks of the conveyance of a corrupt and sinful nature to Adam’s posterity as the
grand point to be proved by the maintainers of the doctrine of original sin.
In order to demonstrate what is asserted in the proposition laid down, there is need
only that these two things should be made manifest: one is this fact, that all mankind come
conceive, is not a dispensation suitable to the infirmity of the human nature in our present state; or it doth not
seem congruous to the goodness of God, to afford us no other way of salvation but by a law, which, if we once
transgress, we are ruined for ever. For who then from the beginning of the world could be saved? And therefore
it seems to me, that the law was not absolutely intended to be a rule for obtaining life, even to Adam in paradise:
Grace was the dispensation God intended mankind should be under; and therefore Christ was fore-ordained
before the foundation of the world.”—There are various other passages in this author’s writings of the like kind.
938
SECTION I. All men tend to sin and ruin.