Chapter XIX.—The
Sophistical Sense Put by Heretics on the Phrase “Resurrection of
the Dead,” As If It Meant the Moral Change of a New
Life.
Now this consideration of the phrase in question, and
its signification—besides maintaining, of course, the true
meaning of the important words—must needs contribute to this
further result, that whatever obscurity our adversaries throw over the
subject under the pretence of figurative and allegorical language, the
truth will stand out in clearer light, and out of uncertainties certain
and definite rules will be prescribed. For some, when they have
alighted on a very usual form of prophetic statement, generally
expressed in figure and allegory, though not always, distort into some
imaginary sense even the most clearly described doctrine of the
resurrection of the dead, alleging that even death itself must be
understood in a spiritual sense. They say that which is commonly
supposed to be death is not really so,—namely, the separation of
body and soul: it is rather the ignorance of God, by reason of which
man is dead to God, and is not less buried in error than he would be in
the grave. Wherefore that also must be held to be the resurrection,
when a man is reanimated by access to the truth, and having dispersed
the death of ignorance, and being endowed with new life
by God, has burst forth from the
sepulchre of the old man, even as the Lord likened the scribes and
Pharisees to “whited sepulchres.”
7394
Whence it follows that they who have by faith attained to the
resurrection, are with the Lord after they have once put Him on in
their baptism. By such subtlety, then, even in conversation have they
often been in the habit of misleading our brethren, as if they held a
resurrection of the dead
as well as we
. Woe, say they, to him
who has not risen in the present body; for they fear that they might
alarm their hearers if they at once denied the resurrection. Secretly,
however, in their minds they think this: Woe betide the simpleton who
during his present life fails to discover the mysteries of heresy;
since this, in their view, is the resurrection. There are
however, a great many also, who, claiming to hold a resurrection after
the soul’s departure, maintain that going out of the sepulchre
means escaping out of the world, since in their view the world is the
habitation of the dead—that is, of those who know not God; or
they will go so far as to say that it actually means escaping out of
the body itself, since they imagine that the body detains the soul,
when it is shut up in the death of a worldly life, as in a
grave.
7394
Matt. xxiii. 27
.