THEODORET.
the same instant, there is in these two speeches that mutual circulation before mentioned.
In the one there is attributed to God or the Lord of Glory death, whereof divine nature
is not capable; in the other ubiquitj- imto man, which human nature admitteth not.
Therefore by the Lord of Glorj- we must needs understand the whole person of Christ,
who being Lord of Glon-, was indeed crucified, but not in that nature for which he is
termed the Lord of Glory. In like manner by the Son of Man the whole person of Christ
must necessarily be meant, who being man upon earth, filled heaven with his glorious
presence, but not according to that nature for which the title of Man is given him.
Without this caution the Fathers whose belief was divine and their meaning most sound,
shall seem in their writing one fo deny what another constantly doth affirm. Theodoret
disputedi with great earnestness that God cannot be said to suffer. But he thereby
meaneth Christ's divine nature against ApoUinarius, which held even Deity itself passible. Cyril on the other side against Nestorius as much contendeth that whosoever
will deny very God to have suffered death doth forsake the faith. Which notNvithstanding
to hold were heresy, if the name of God in this assertion did not import as it doth the
person of Christ, who being verily God suffered death, but in the flesh, and not in that
substance for which the name of God is given him." '
As to the part played by Theodoret throughout the whole controversv we may
c«nclude that though he had to own himself beaten intellectually, j-et the honours of the
moral victory remain with him rather than with his illustrious opponent. Not for the
last time in the history of the Church a great duel of dialectic issued in a conclusion
wherein of the champion who was driven to say, " I was wrong," the congregation of the faithful has yet {)erfQrce felt that he was right.
The end is well known. Theodosius summoned the bishops to Ephesus at the
Pentecost of 431. There arrived Cyril with fifty supporters early in June; there arrived
Theodoret with his Metropolitan Alexander of Hierapolis, in advance of the rest of the
Orientals. The Cyrillians were vainly entreated to wait for John of Antioch and his part}-,
and opened the Council without them. When they arrived they would not join the
Council, and set up their own " Conciliabulum " apart. Under the hot Levantine sun of
July and August the two parties denounced one another on the one side for not accepting
the condemnation of Nestorius, which the Cyrillians had passed in the beginning of their
proceedings, on the other for the informality- and injustice of the condemnation. Then
deputies from the Orientals, of whom Theodoret was one, hurried to Constantinople, but
were allowed to proceed no further than Chalcedon. The letters written by Theodoret
at this time to his friends among the bishops and at the court, and his petitions to the
Emperor,' leave a vivid impression of the zeal, vigour and industry of the writer, as well
as of the extraordinary literary- readiness which could pour out letter after letter, memorial
after memorial, amid all the excitement of controversy, the weariness of travel, the
sojourning in strange and uncomfortable quarters, and the tension of anxietj- as to an uncertain future.
Though Nestorius was deposed his friends protested that they would continue true to
him, and Theodoret was one of the synod held at Tarsus, and of another at Antioch, in
which the protest against Cyril's action was renewed. But the oriental bishops were now
themselves undergoing a process of scission,' John of Antioch and Acacius of Beroea heading the peacemakers who were anxious to come to terms yvith Cyril, while Alexander
of Hierapolis led the irreconcilables. Intellectually Theodoret shrank from concession,
but his moral instincts were all in favour of peace. He himself drew up a declaration of
faith which was presented by Paul of Emesa to Cyril, which Cyril accepted. But still true
to his friend, Theodoret refused to accept the deposition of Nestorius and his individual
condemnation, and it was not till several years had elapsed that, moved less by the threat of
exile and forfeiture, as the imperial penalty for refusing to accept the position, than by the en-
treaties of his beloved flock and of his favourite ascetic solitaries that he would not leave them,
Theodoret found means of attaching a meaning to the current anathemas on Nestorianism,
not, as he said, on Nestorius, which allowed him to submit. He even entered into friendly
correspondence with Cyril.* But the truce was hollow. Cyril was indignant to find that Theodoret still maintained his old opinions. At last the protracted quarrel was ended by
Cyril's death in June, 444. On the famous letter over which so many battles of criticism have been fought wc
» II f . H *,"?°''"- .?'='=• ^°^-;f- 'Hj; ■»• V, ^ ^iJlt? CLVU., CLVHI., CLXVII, CLXVIII., CLXIX., CLXX. » Hefclc. Hist. Consc. m. w;. Can. Veiwblcs. Diet. Christ. Siog. Iv. 910. « Ep. LXXXIII.