Among these Festal Letters, the nineteenth,
intended for Easter 347, and therefore composed in the beginning of
that year, had been rewritten in Alexandria, as the introduction
expressly states. This confirms the statement of the Historia
Acephala, that Athanasius was already returned to Alexandria in
October, 346, and confirms the chief points of Mansi’s
hypothesis; while, on the other hand, it unanswerably refutes, by
Athanasius’ own testimony, the statements of Socrates and Sozomen
(which, from their dependence on each other, only count as one), with
reference to the date 347.