If any one should say, there is no need that the Indifference should be perfect; but al-
though a former inclination still remains, yet, if it be not very strong, possibly the strength
of the Will may oppose and overcome it:—This is grossly absurd; for the strength of the
Will, let it be never so great, gives it no such sovereignty and command, as to cause itself to
prefer and not to prefer at the same time, or to choose contrary to its own present choice.
Therefore, if there be the least degree of antecedent preponderation of the Will, it must
be perfectly abolished, before the Will can be at liberty to determine itself the contrary way.
And if the Will determines itself the same way, it was not a free determination, because the
Will is not wholly at liberty in so doing; its determination is not altogether from itself, but
it was partly determined before, in its prior inclination: and all the freedom the Will exercises
in the case, is in an increase of inclination, which it gives itself, added to what it had by a
foregoing bias; so much is from itself, and so much is from perfect indifference. For though
the Will had a previous tendency that way, yet as to that additional degree of inclination, it
had no tendency. Therefore the previous tendency is of no consideration, with respect to
the act wherein the Will is free. So that it comes to the same thing which was said at first,
that as to the act of the Will, wherein the Will is free, there must be perfect Indifference, or
equilibrium.
To illustrate this: suppose a sovereign self-moving power in a natural body; but that the
body is in motion already, by an antecedent bias; for instance, gravitation towards the centre
of the earth; and has one degree of motion by virtue of that previous tendency; but by its
self-moving power it adds one degree more to its motion, and moves so much move swiftly
towards the centre of the earth than it would do by its gravity only: it is evident, all that is
owing to a self-moving power in this case, is the additional degree of motion; and that the
other degree which it had from gravity, is of no consideration in the case; the effect is just
the same, as if the body had received from itself one degree of motion from a state of perfect
rest. So, if we suppose a self-moving power given to the scale of a balance, which has a weight
of one degree beyond the opposite scale; and if we ascribe to it an ability to add to itself an-
other degree of force the same way, by its self-moving power; this is just the same thing as
to ascribe to it a power to give itself one degree of preponderation from a perfect equilibrium;
and so much power as the scale has to give itself an over-balance from a perfect equipoise,
so much self-moving self-preponderating power it has, and no more. So that its free power
this way is always to be measured from perfect equilibrium.
I need say no more to prove, that if Indifference be essential to Liberty, it must be perfect
Indifference; and that so far as the Will is destitute of this, so far is it destitute of that freedom
by which it is in a capacity of being its own determiner, without being at all passive, or
subject to the power and sway of something else, in its motions and determinations.
569
SECTION VII. Concerning the notion of Liberty of Will, consisting in Indifference.…