What, then, is the reason that
when we count one by one those who are exhibited to us in one nature,
we ordinarily name them in the plural and speak of “so many
men,” instead of calling them all one: while in the case of the
Divine nature our doctrinal definition rejects the plurality of Gods,
at once enumerating the Persons, and at the same time not admitting the
plural signification? Perhaps one might seem to touch the point if he
were to say (speaking offhand to straightforward people), that the
definition refused to reckon Gods in any number to avoid any
resemblance to the polytheism of the heathen, lest, if we too were to
enumerate the Deity, not in the singular, but in the plural, as they
are accustomed to do, there might be supposed to be also some community
of doctrine. This answer, I say, if made to people of a more guileless
spirit, might seem to be of some weight: but in the case of the others
who require that one of the alternatives they propose should be
established (either that we should not acknowledge the Godhead in Three
Persons, or that, if we do, we should speak of those who share in the
same Godhead as three), this answer is not such as to furnish any
solution of the difficulty. And hence we must needs make our reply at
greater length, tracing out the truth as best we may; for the question
is no ordinary one.