31. As regards your attempt to show that railing and
murder, the use of the expression raca and adultery, the idle
word and godlessness, are rewarded with the same punishment, I have
already given you my reply, and will now briefly repeat it. You must
either deny that you are a sinner if you are not to be in danger of
Gehenna: or, if you are a sinner you will be sent to hell for even a
light offence: Wisd. i. 11.“The mouth
that lieth,” says one, “kills the soul.” I suspect
that you, like other men, have occasionally told a lie: Ps. cxvi. 11; Rom. iii. 4.for all men are liars, that God alone may
be true, Ps. li. 4.and that He may be justified in
His words, and may prevail when He judges. It follows either that you
will not be a man lest you be found a liar: or if you are a man and are
consequently a liar, you will be punished with parricides and
adulterers. For you admit no difference between sins, and the gratitude
of those whom you raise from the mire and set on high will not equal
the rage against you of those whom for the trifling offences of daily
life you have thrust into utter darkness. And if it be so that in a
persecution one is stifled, another beheaded, another flees, or the
fourth dies within the walls of a prison, and one crown of victory
awaits various kinds of struggle, the fact tells in our favour. For in
martyrdom it is the will, which gives occasion to the death, that is
crowned. My duty is to resist the
frenzy of the heathen, and not deny the Lord. It rests with them either
to behead, or to burn, or to shut up in prison, or enforce various
other penalties. But if I escape, and die in solitude, there will not
at my death be the same crown for me as for them, because the
confession of Christ will not have been to me as to them the cause of
death. As for your remark that absolutely no difference was made
between the brother who had always been with his father, and him who
was afterwards welcomed as a penitent, I am willing to add, if you
like, that the one drachma which was lost and was found was put with
the others, and that the one sheep which the good shepherd, leaving the
ninety and nine, sought and brought back, made up the full tale of a
hundred. But it is one thing to be a penitent, and with tears sue for
pardon, another to be always with the father. And so both the shepherd
and the father say by the mouth of Ezekiel to the sheep that was
carried back, and to the son that was lost, Ezek. xvi. 62, 63.“And I will establish my covenant
with thee; and thou shalt know that I am the Lord: that thou mayest
remember, and be confounded, and never open thy mouth ever more,
because of thy shame, when I have forgiven thee all that thou hast
done.” That penitents may have their due it is enough for them to
feel shame instead of all other punishment. Hence in another place it
is said to them, Ezek. xxxvi. 31, 32. “Then
shall ye remember your evil ways, and all the crimes wherewith ye were
defiled, and ye shall loathe yourselves in your own sight for all the
wickedness that ye have done; and ye shall know that I am the Lord,
when I shall have done you good for my name’s sake, and not
according to your evil ways, nor according to your evil doings.”
The son, moreover, was reproved by his father for envying his
brother’s deliverance, and for being tormented by jealousy while
the angels in heaven were rejoicing. The parallel, however, is not to
be drawn between the merits of the two sons (one of whom was temperate,
the other a prodigal) and those of the whole human race, but the
characters depicted are either Jews and Christians, or saints and
penitents. In the lifetime of Bishop Damasus I dedicated to him a small
treatise upon this parable. Letter XXI.