Book v1.] ARNOBIUS ADVERSUS GENTES. 939
ceremonies,’ and are used largely in your religious acts. And,
first, with respect to that very incense which you use, we ask
this of you particularly, whence or at what time you have
been able to become acquainted with it, and to know it, so
that you have just reason to think that it is either it to
be given to the gods, or most agreeable to their desires. For
it is almost a novelty ; and there is no endless succession of
years since it began to be known in these parts, and won its
way into the shrines of the gods. For neither in the heroic
ages, as it is believed and declared, was it known what in-
cense was, as is proved by the ancient writers, in whose
books is found no mention? of it; nor was Etruria, the
parent and mother of superstition, acquainted with its fame
and renown, as the rites of the chapels prove; nor was it
used by any one in offering sacrifice during the four hundred
years in which Alba flourished; nor did even Romulus or
Numa, [who was] skilful in devising new ceremonies, know
either of its existence or growth, as the sacred grits? show
with which it was customary that the usual sacrifices should
be performed. Whence, therefore, did its use begin to be
adopted? or what [desire of] novelty assailed the old and
ancient custom, so that that which was not needed for so
many ages took the first place in the ceremonies? For if
without incense the performance of a religious service is im-
perfect, and if a quantity of it is necessary to make the celes-
tials gentle and propitious to men, the ancients fell into sin,
nay rather, their whole life was full of guilt, for they care-
lessly neglected to offer that which was most fitted to give
pleasure to the gods. But if in ancient times neither men
nor gods sought for this incense, it is proved that to-day
also that is offered uselessly and in vain which antiquity did
not believe necessary, but modern times desired without any
reason.
1 Lit., * these kinds of ceremonies, too, were coupled and mixed," ete.
? On this Oehler remarks, that the books of Moses show that it was
certainly used in the East in the most ancient times. But Arnobius has
expressly restricted his statement to the use of incense ** in these parts."
3 Pium far.