“To establish this insane
doctrine they insult the Scriptures, and bring forward what is said in
the Psalms of Christ, ‘Thou hast loved righteousness and hated
iniquity, therefore thy God hath anointed thee with the oil of gladness
above thy fellows Ps. xlv. 7, as in Sept.,
except that ἀδικίαν is substituted for ἀνομίαν.’ Now that the
Son of God was not created out of the non-existent Οὔτε ἐξ οὐκ
ὄντων
γεγένηται, and that there never was a time in which
He was not, is expressly taught by John the Evangelist, who speaks of
Him as ‘the only begotten Son which is in the bosom of the
Father John i. 18.’ This divine teacher desired
to show that the Father and the Son are inseparable; and, therefore, he
said, ‘that the Son is in the bosom of the Father.’
Moreover, the same John affirms that the Word of God is not classed
among things created out of the non-existent, for, he says that
‘all things were made by Him John i. 3,’ and he also declares His
individual personality ὑπόστασιν in the following
words: ‘In the beginning was the Word, and the Word was with
God, and the Word was God.…All things were made by Him, and
without Him was not any thing made that was made John i. 1, 3.’ If, then, all things were made by
Him, how is it that He who thus bestowed existence on all, could at any
period have had no existence himself? The Word, the creating power, can
in no way be defined as of the same nature as the things created, if
indeed He was in the beginning, and all things were made by Him, and
were called by Him out of the non-existent into being. ‘That
which is τὸ ὄν, the
self-existent of philosophy.’ must be of an opposite
nature to, and essentially different from, things created out of the
non-existent. This shows, likewise, that there is no separation between
the Father and the Son, and that the idea of separation cannot even be
conceived by the mind; while the fact that the world was created out of
the non-existent involves a later and fresh genesis of its essential
nature The
history of the word ὑπόστασις is of crucial value in the study of the Arian controversy.
Its various usages may be classified as (i) Classical; (ii)
Scriptural; (iii) Ecclesiastical. The correlative
substantive of the verb ὑφίστημι, I make to stand under, [from ὑπό
= sub. under, and ἵστημι, [STA]; it
means primarily a standing under. Hence, materially, it means in
(i) Classical Greek, sediment, prop. foundation: substances as opposed
to their reflexions, substantial nature, as of timber [Theoph. C. P. 5.
16. 4]. So naturally grew the signification of ground of hope, actual
existence; and, in the later philosophy, it had come to be employed
instead of οὐσία for the
noetic substratum “underlying” the phænomena. (ii)
Scriptural. In the N.T. it is found five times, twice in 2 Cor. and
thrice in Heb. (α) 2 Cor. ix. 4, and (β) xi. 17.
“Confidence” of boasting. (γ) Heb. i. 3, ὁ χαρακτὴρ
τῆς
ὑποστάσεως, A.V. the express image of His “person.” R.V.,
the very image of His “substance.” (δ) Heb. iii. 14,
“Confidence”. (ε) Heb. xi. 1, A.V.
“substance” of things hoped for. R.V. Assurance of things
hoped for. (iii) Ecclesiastical. The earlier ecclesiastical use, like
the later philosophical, identified it with οὐσία,
and so the Nicene Confession anathematized those who maintained the Son
to be of a different substance or essence from the Father (ὑποστάσεως ἢ
οὐσίας). In the
version of Hilary of Poictiers (de Synodis, §84; Op. ii.
510) οὐσία is
translated by “substantia,” the etymological equivalent
of ὑπόστασις, except in the phrase quoted, when “substantia aut
essentia” represents οὐσία by its
own etymological equivalent “essentia.” Thus in a.d. 325 to have contended for τρεῖς
ὑποστάσεις
would have been heretical. But as the subtilty of
controversy required greater nicety of phrase, it was laid down (Basil
the Great, Ep. 38) that while οὐσία is an
universal denoting that which is common to the individuals of a
species, ὑπόστασις makes an individual that which it is, and constitutes
personal existence. Hence μία
ὑπόστασις became Sabellian, and τρεῖς
οὐσίαι Arian,
while τρεῖς
ὑποστάσεις
was orthodox. cf Theod. Dial. i. 7. Eranistes loq.
“Is there any distinction between οὐσία and ὑπόστασις?”
Orthodoxus. “In
extra-Christian philosophy there is not; for οὐσία signifies τὸ
ὄν, that which is, and ὑπόστασις that which subsists. But according to the doctrine of the
Fathers there is the same difference between οὐσία and ὑπόστασις as between the common and the particular; the race, and the
species or individual.”…“The Divine οὐσία (substance) means the Holy Trinity; but the ὑπόστασις indicates any πρόσωπον (person) as of the Father, the Son, or of the Holy Ghost.
For we who follow the definitions of the Fathers assert ὑπόστασις, πρόσωπον and ἰδιότης (substantial nature, person, or individuality) to mean the
same thing.” Vide also Newman’s Arians of the Fourth
Century, Appendix, Note iv. fourth Edition., all things having been endowed with such
an origin of existence by the Father through the Son. John, the most
pious apostle, perceiving that the word ‘was’ applied to
the Word of God “In the beginning was the word.” John i.
1 was far beyond
and above the intelligence of created beings, did not presume to speak
of His generation or creation, nor yet dared to name the Maker and the
creature in equivalent syllables. Not that the Son of God is
unbegotten, for the Father alone is unbegotten; but that the ineffable
personality of the only-begotten God is beyond the keenest
conception of the evangelists and perhaps even of angels. Therefore, I
do not think men ought to be considered pious who presume to
investigate this subject, in disobedience to the injunction,
‘Seek not what is too difficult for thee, neither enquire into
what is too high for thee Ecclus. iii. 21.’ For if the
knowledge of many other things incomparably inferior is beyond the
capacity of the human mind, and cannot therefore be attained, as has
been said by Paul, ‘Eye hath not seen, nor ear heard, neither
have entered into the heart of man, the things which God hath prepared
for them that love Him 1 Cor. ii. 9,’ and as God
also said to Abraham, that the stars could not be numbered by him Gen. xv. 5; and it is likewise said, ‘Who
shall number the grains of sand by the sea-shore, or the drops of
rain Ecclus. i. 2?’ how then can any one but a
madman presume to enquire into the nature of the Word of God? It is
said by the Spirit of prophecy, ‘Who shall declare His
generation Isai. liii. 8?’ And, therefore, our
Saviour in His kindness to those men who were the pillars of the whole
world, desiring to relieve them of the burden of striving after this
knowledge, told them that it was beyond their natural comprehension,
and that the Father alone could discern this most divine mystery;
‘No man,’ said He, ‘knoweth the Son but the
Father, and no man knoweth the Father save the Son Matt. xi. 27.’ It was, I think, concerning this
same subject that the Father said, ‘My secret is for Me and for
Mine Is. xxiv. 16: “My
leanness, my leanness, woe unto me.” A.V. “Secretum meum
mihi.” Vulg..’