Gibbon, Chap.
xxi. n.
referring to the three ecclesiastical historians of this period speaks
of “Socrates, the more curious Sozomen, and the learned
Theodoret.” Of learning, industry, and veracity the proofs are
patent in the book itself. The chief fault of the work is its want of
chronological arrangement. Ceillier (x. 42) repeats the charge of distinct errors in
chronology in (a) the statement that Arius died in 325 instead of in
336; (b) the extension of the exile of Athanasius by four months; (c)
the election of Ambrose at the beginning of the reign of Valentinian,
instead of ten years later; (d) the troubles at Antioch placed after
instead of before those at Thessalonica; (e) the siege of Nisibis in
350 confounded with that of 359. As to (a) the truth is that Theodoret
is guilty rather of vagueness than of a misstatement. (Vide I. capp.
xiii, xiv.) The objection to (b) the two years and four months exile of
Athanasius is due to Valerius (obs. Ecc. i). Canon Bright (Dict.
Christ. Biog. i. 187) agrees with Theodoret (cf. Newman Hist. Tracts
xii and Hefele, Conciliengesch. i. 467.) In (c) Theodoret is vague, in
(d) wrong. According to Valerius Volagesus, and not Jacobus, was bishop
of Nisibis in 350. A minor
shortcoming is what may be called a lack of perspective; a fulness of
detail is sometimes conceded to mere episode and parenthesis, while
characters and events of high and crucial importance would scarcely be
known to be so, were we dependent for our estimation of them on
Theodoret alone. Valesius inclines to the opinion that his opening
words about supplying things omitted τῆς
ἐκκλησιαστικῆς
ἱστορίας τὰ
παραλειπόμενα refer to
Socrates and Sozomen, and compares him in his composition of a history
after those writers (there is just a possibility that he might have
completed the parallel by referring to a third
predecessor—Rufinus) to St. John filling up the gaps left by the
synoptists. Valesii annotationes—Theod: Migne III. 1522. Valesius is the
Latinized form of Henri de Valois, French historiographer royal, who
edited Ammianus Marcellinus and the Greek Ecclesiastical historians. He
died in 1692. But this view is open to question.
Theodoret names no previous writers but Eusebius. A special importance
attaches to his account of such events and persons as his local
knowledge enables him to give with completeness of detail, as for
instance, all that relates to Antioch and its bishops. Garnerius is of
opinion that the work might with propriety be entitled A History of the
Arian Heresy; all other matter introduced he views as merely
episodic. Theod.
Ed. Migne. V. 282. He also quotes the letter Ep.
XXXIV. of Gregory the great in which the Roman
bishop states that “the apostolic see refuses to receive the
History of ‘Sozomenus’ (sic) inasmuch as it abounds with
lies, and praises Theodore of Mopsuestia, maintaining that he was up to
the day of his death, a great Doctor.” “Sozomen” is
supposed to be a slip of the pen, or of the memory, for
“Theodoret.” But, if this be so, “multa
mentitur” is an unfair description of the errors of the
historian. Fallible he was, and exhibits failure in accuracy,
especially in chronology, but his truthfulness of aim is plain. “Baronius obviously approves of Gregory’s remark about
Theodoret’s lies, that is his errors in the order of events, and
out of Book iv. produces no less than fifteen blunders, to say nothing
of those in iii and v.” Garner. loc. cit. 280, 281.