It is no doubt possible that Ephraim may have visited Egypt, The shorter
Syriac Life agrees in affirming the fact of his visit to Egypt,
but says nothing of its duration. No other authority, earlier or
contemporary, hints at it. as the
Life affirms, before proceeding to Cæsarea: as an
anchorite he would naturally be drawn to the land where the anchorite
life had its origin and its greatest development. Yet it is
hardly probable that, eager as he was to see Basil at Cæsarea, he
would, when setting out on his travels, have directed his course to
Egypt first,—a country so distant, and lying in a direction so
different, from Cappadocia. This improbability would naturally
fail to strike our biographer, who appears to have supposed
Basil’s Cæsarea (if indeed he had any definite idea of its
situation) to have been the maritime city of that name in
Palestine. One can hardly avoid suspecting that this whole
narrative of the visit to Egypt—unknown as it is to all
authorities save our Life (in its twofold recension), and the
shorter form of the same—may have been invented by some compiler
or reviser, writing in, or for, one of the Egyptian monasteries of the
Nitrian Desert, and seeking to gratify the Syrian ascetics who were
numerous in that region, by making it the scene of an episode in the
life of the most famous of Syrian ascetics. It certainly has the
air of an interpolation, coming as it does between the description of
Ephraim’s longing desire to see Basil, and the narrative of the
fulfilment of that desire by his visit to Cæsarea. More
particularly, as regards the story of the visit of Ephraim to the
Nitrian Saint Pesoës (or Bishoi), it is to be noted that it is
mentioned, not in the Parisian recension of the Life, but only
in that of the Vatican ms. It is a
significant fact that this ms., which is thus
our only written authority for the alleged visit, was written
(probably) about the year 1100, in the Nitrian monastery of “Amba
Bishoi” (St. Pesoës). Assemani,
Biblioth. Orient., I., p. 46, note 1. On the
other hand, it is to be added that a tradition of Ephraim’s
sojourn in Egypt, connecting him with Pesoës, lingered in quite
recent times, and may probably still linger, among the monks, Syrian
and Coptic, of the Nitrian region. Travellers of the seventeenth,
and even eighteenth, century, tell of a tamarind tree which was shown
to them within the precincts of the Syrian monastery of the Theotokos
in that region, reputed to have grown from Ephraim’s staff which
he set in the ground on his arrival there, as he was about to enter the cell of Pesoës. It is mentioned by Huntington
(afterwards Provost of Trinity College, Dublin, and finally Bishop of
Raphoe) who visited the place, 1678–9 (see his
Epistolæ, XXXIX., p. 69): again by J. S. Assemani in
1715 (see reference in note 6). More recent visitors (Lord de la
Zouche in 1837, and Archdeacon Tattam in 1839) do not speak of
it.
Of the Nitrian monasteries (reputed to have once numbered fifty, or even more), the principal one, that of
the Theotokos, whence the libraries of the Vatican and of the British
museum have derived their most precious acquisitions of Syriac
mss., belongs to the Syrian Jacobites, whose
Church has always been in full communion with that of the Copts.
A second belongs to the Copts; a third to the Greeks. The fourth
(that of St. Pesoës) does not appear to be specially appropriated,
but to be mainly Coptic, though (as appears above) not to the exclusion
of Syrians. It is
probable that this legend of the staff (which reminds one of that of
the staff of St. Joseph of Arimathea and the Glastonbury thorn tree)
may have grown out of the belief that Ephraim once visited the
monastery,—which belief again may have been originated by the
pious fiction of the compiler or interpolator of the Life in its
Vatican form. It is easy to imagine how gladly a community of
Syrian monks in this Egyptian solitude would listen to what professed
to be a record of the greatest of Syrian monks, a recluse like
themselves, the author of the Sermons to Ascetics which they had read
or listened to, and of the many hymns which enriched their offices and
quickened their devotions;—and how ready they would be to welcome
as fact the story of his sojourn in their valley, and to imagine that a
memorial of it survived among the trees of their garden.