lives. This doctrine is far removed
from that of Philo, i.e. from the Alexandrine philosophy. The
very first statement of S. John represents the Λόγος as
having a backward movement towards the Deity, as well as a forward
movement from Him; as held there, and yet sent thence by a force which
he calls Love, so that the primal movement towards the world does not
come from the Λόγος, but from
the Father Himself. The Λόγος here is
the Word, and not the Reason; He is the living effect of a
living cause, not a theory or hypothesis standing at the gateway of an
insoluble mystery. The Λόγος speaks
because the Father speaks, not because the Supreme cannot and will not
speak; and their relations are often the reverse of those they hold in
Philo; for the Father becomes at times the meditator between the
Λόγος and the world drawing men towards Him and subduing portions
of the Creation before His path. Psychology seems to pour a light
straight into the Council-chamber of the Eternal; while Metaphysics had
turned away from it, with her finger on her lips. Philo may have used,
as Tholuck thinks, those very texts of the Old Testament which support
the Christian doctrine of the Word, and in the translation of which the
LXX. supplied him with the Greek word. But, however derived, his
theology eventually ranged itself with those pantheistic views of the
universe which subdued all thinking minds not Christianized, for more
than three centuries after him. The majority of recent critics
certainly favour the supposition that the Λόγος of Philo
is a being numerically distinct from the Supreme; but when the relation
of the Supreme is attentively traced in each, the actual antagonism of
the Christian system and his begins to be apparent. The Supreme of
Philo is not and can never be related to the world. The Λόγος is a logical necessity as a mediator between the two; a
spiritual being certainly, but only the head of a long series of such
beings, who succeed at last in filling the passage between the finite
and the infinite. In this system there is no mission of love and of
free will; such beings are but as the milestones to mark the distance
between man and the Great Unknown. It is significant that Vacherot, the
leading historian of the Alexandrine school of philosophy, doubts
whether John the Evangelist ever even heard of the Jewish philosopher
of Alexandria. It is pretty much the same with the members of the
Neoplatonic Triad as with the Λόγος of Philo.
The God of Plotinus and Proclus is not a God in three hypostases: he is
simply one, Intelligence and Soul being his necessary emanations; they
are in God, but they are not God: Soul is but a hypostasis of a
hypostasis. The One is not a hypostasis, but above it. This
“Trinity” depends on the distinction and succession of the
necessary movements of the Deity; it consists of three distinct
and separate principles of things. The Trinity is really peculiar to
Christianity. Three inseparable Hypostases make equally a part of the
Divine nature, so that to take away one would be to destroy the whole.
The Word and Spirit are Divine, not intermediaries disposed in a
hierarchy on the route of the world to God. As Plotinus reproached the
Gnostics, the Christian mysticism despises the world, and suppressing
the intermediaries who in other doctrines serve to elevate the soul
gradually to God, it transports it by one impulse as it were into the
Divine nature. The Christian goes straight to God by Faith. The
Imagination, Reason, and Contemplation of the Neoplatonists,
i.e. the three movements of the soul which correspond to their
lower “trinity” of Nature, Soul, Intelligence, are no
longer necessary. There is an antipathy profound between the two
systems; How then could the one be said to influence the other?
Neoplatonism may have tinged Christianity, while it was still seeking
for language in which to express its inner self: but it never
influenced the intrinsically moral character of the Christian Creeds.
The Alexandrine philosophy is all metaphysics, and its rock was
pantheism; all, even matter, proceeds from God necessarily and
eternally. The Church never hesitated: she saw the abyss that opens
upon that path; and by severe decrees she has closed the way to
pantheism.