Rhodo had probably brought forward against Apelles proof from
prophecy which led to the discussion of the Old Testament prophecies in
general. Although Apelles had rejected Marcion’s dualism, and
accepted the “one principle,” he still rejected the Old
Testament. This is quite peculiar, and yet perfectly comprehensible;
for while Marcion was indeed the only one of that age that understood
Paul, yet as Harnack well says, even he misunderstood him; and neither
himself nor his followers were able to rise to Paul’s noble
conception of the Old Testament law as a “schoolmaster to bring
us to Christ,” and thus a part of the good God’s general
plan of salvation. It took, perhaps, a born Jew, as Paul was, to reach
that high conception of the law in those days. To Marcion and his
followers the law seemed to stand in irreconcilable conflict with the
Gospel,—Jewish law on the one side, Gospel liberty on the
other,—they could not reconcile them; they must, therefore,
reject the former as from another being, and not from the God of the
Gospel. There was in that age no historical interpretation of the Old
Testament. It must either be interpreted allegorically, and made a
completely Christian book, or else it must be rejected as opposed to
Christianity. Marcion and his followers, in their conception of law and
Gospel as necessarily opposed, could follow only the latter course.
Marcion, in his rejection of the Old Testament, proceeded simply upon
dogmatic presumptions. Apelles, although his rejection of it
undoubtedly originated in the same presumptions, yet subjected it to a
criticism which satisfied him of the correctness of his position, and
gave him a fair basis of attack. His procedure was, therefore, more
truly historical than that of Marcion, and anticipated modern methods
of higher criticism.