“The Marcellians,” called after Marcellus
bishop of Ancyra, who was persistently denounced not only by the
Arianizers, but by St. Basil, and for a time, at least, suspected by
St. Athanasius (Vide Epiphan., Hær., 72, 4) as one
who held notions akin to Sabellianism, and fatal to a true belief in
the Divine Sonship and the Incarnation. The theory ascribed to
him was that the Logos was an impersonal Divine power, immanent from
eternity in God, but issuing from him in the act of creation, and
entering at last into relations with the human person of Jesus, who
thus became God’s Son. But this expansion of the original
divine unity would be followed by a “contraction,” when the
Logos would retire from Jesus, and God would again be all in all.
Some nine years before the council, Marcellus, then in extreme old age,
had sent his deacon Eugenius to St. Athanasius, with a written
confession of faith, quite orthodox as to the eternity of the Trinity,
and the identity of the Logos with a pre-existing and personal Son,
although not verbally explicit as to the permanence of Christ’s
“kingdom,”—the point insisted on in one of the
Epiphanian-Constantinopolitan additions to the Creed (Montfaucon,
Collect. Nov., ii., 1). The question whether Marcellus was
personally heterodox—i.e. whether the extracts from his treatise,
made by his adversary Eusebius of Cæsarea, give a fair account of
his real views—has been answered unfavourably by some writers, as
Newman (Athanasian Treatises, ii., 200, ed. 2), and
Döllinger (Hippolytus and Callistus, p. 217, E. T. p. 201),
while others, like Neale, think that “charity and truth”
suggest his “acquittal” (Hist. Patr. Antioch., p.
106). Montfaucon thinks that his written statements might be
favourably interpreted, but that his oral statements must have given
ground for suspicion.