9. So much for his prolix defence of himself or I should
rather say his attack on me. In this letter I have only answered him
briefly and cursorily that from what I have said he may perceive what I
do not say, and may know that as I am a human being I am a rational
animal and well able to understand his shrewdness, and that I am not so
obtuse or brutish as to catch only the sound of his words and not their
meaning. I now ask of you to pardon my chagrin and to allow that if it
is arrogant to answer back, it is yet more arrogant to bring baseless
charges. Yet my answer has indicated what I might have said rather than
has actually said it. Why do men look for peace at a distance? and why
do they wish to have it enforced by word of command? Let them shew
themselves peacemakers, and peace will follow at once. Why do they use
the name of your holiness to terrorize us, when your
letter—strange contrast to their harsh and menacing
words—breathes only peace and meekness? For that the letter which
Isidore the presbyter has brought for me from you does make for peace
and harmony I know by this, that these insincere professors of a wish
for peace have refused to deliver it to me. Let them choose whichever
alternative they please. Either I am a good man or I am a bad one. If I
am a good one let them leave me in quiet: if I am a bad one, why do
they desire to be in bad company? Surely my opponent has learnt by
experience the value of humility. He who now tears asunder things
which, formerly separate, he of his own will put together, proves that
in severing now what he then joined, he is acting at the instigation of
another. Probably Isidore,
who had taken a view hostile to Jerome, and who at this time fell under
the displeasure of Theophilus.