The
Eusebians alleged that, fifty-four Bishops of the two parties of S.
Alexander and Meletius being assembled for the election, and having
sworn to elect by the common voice, six or seven of these broke their
oaths in favour of S. Athanasius, whom no one had thought of, and
consecrated him in secret to the great surprise and scandal of both
ecclesiastical and lay persons. vid. Socr. ii. 17. Philostorgius (a.d. 425) adds particulars, explanatory or
corrective of this statement, of which the Bishops in the text do not
seem to have heard; viz., that Athanasius with his party one night
seized on the Church of St. Dionysius, and compelled two Bishops whom
he found there to consecrate him against their will; that he was in
consequence anathematized by all the other Bishops, but that,
fortifying himself in his position, he sent in his election to the
Emperor, and by this means obtained its confirmation. H. E. ii.
16. It appears, in matter of fact, that S. Athan. was absent at time of
his election; as Socrates says, in order to avoid it, or as Epiphanius,
on business at the Court; these reasons are compatible. [Cf. Prolegg.
ch. ii. §4, and Gwatkin’s note, quoted there.]