But, like some viscous and
sticky clay, the nonsense he has concocted in contravention of our
teaching of conception seems to hold us back, and prevent us from
applying ourselves to more important matters. For how can one pass over
his solemn and profound philosophy, as when he says that God’s
greatness is seen not only in the works of His hands, but that His
wisdom is displayed in their names also, adapted as they are with such
peculiar fitness to the nature of each work of His creation Compare with this view of Eunomius on the sacredness of names,
this striking passage from Origen (c. Cels. v. 43). “We hold,
then, that the origin of names is not to be found in any formal
agreements on the part of those who gave them, as Aristotle thinks.
Human language, in fact, did not have its beginning from man. Any one
can see this who reflects upon the real nature of the incantations
which in the different languages are associated with the patriarchal
names of those languages. The names which have their native power in
such and such a language cease to have this influence of their peculiar
sound when they are changed into another language. This has been often
observed in the names given even to living men: one who from his birth
has been called so and so in Greek will never, if we change his name
into Egyptian or Roman, be made to feel or act as he can when called by
the first name given.…If this is true in the case of names given
to men, what are we to think of the names connected in some way or
other with the Deity? For instance, there must be some change in
translating Abraham’s name into Greek: some new expression given
to ‘Isaac,’ and ‘Jacob’: and, while he who
repeats the incantation or the oath names the ‘God of Abraham, of
Isaac, and of Jacob,’ he produces those particular effects by the
mere force and working of those names: because the dæmons are
mustered by him who utters them: but if on the other hand he says,
‘God of the chosen Father of the Crowd,’ ‘of the
Laughter,’ ‘of the Supplanter,’ he can do nothing
with the names so expressed, any more than with any other powerless
instrument.…We can say the same of ‘Sabaoth,’ which
is used in many exorcisms: if we change it to ‘Lord of
Powers,’ or, ‘Lord of Hosts,’ or,
‘Almighty,’ we can do nothing …”—and
(46), “This, too, is the reason why we ourselves prefer any
degradation to that of owning Zeus to be Deity. We cannot conceive of
Zeus as the same as Sabaoth: or as Divine in any of all possible
meanings.…If the Egyptians offer us ‘Ammon,’ or
death, we shall take the latter, rather than pronounce the divinity of
‘Ammon.’ The Scythians may tell us that their Papœus
is the God of the Universe, we shall not listen: we firmly believe in
the God of the Universe, but we must not call him Papœus, making
that a name for absolute Deity, as the Being who occupies the desert,
the nation, and the language of the Scythians would desire: although,
indeed, it cannot be sin for any to use the appellation of the Deity in
his own mother tongue, whether it be the Scythian way or the
Egyptian.”? Having perchance fallen in
with Plato’s Cratylus, or hearing from some one who had met with
it, by reason, I suppose, of his own poverty of ideas, he attached that
nonsense patchwise to his own, acting like those who get their bread by
begging. For just as they, receiving some trifle from each who bestows
it on them, collect their bread from many and various sources, so the
discourse of Eunomius, by reason of his scanty store of the true bread,
assiduously collects scraps of phrases and notions from all quarters.
And thus, being struck by the beauty of the Platonic style, he thinks
it not unseemly to make Plato’s theory a doctrine of the Church.
For by how many appellations, say, is the created firmament called
according to the varieties of language? For we call it Heaven, the
Hebrew calls it Samaim, the Roman cœlum, other names are given to
it by the Syrian, the Mede, the Cappadocian, the African, the Scythian,
the Thracian the Egyptian: nor would it be easy to enumerate the
multiplicity of names which are applied to Heaven and other objects by
the different nations that employ them. Which of these, then, tell me,
is the appropriate word wherein the great wisdom of God is manifested?
If you prefer the Greek to the rest, the Egyptian haply will confront
you with his own. And if you give the first place to the Hebrew, there
is the Syrian to claim precedence for his own word, nor will the Roman
yield the supremacy, nor the Mede allow himself to be outdone; while of
the other nations each will claim the prize. What, then, will be the
fate of his dogma when torn to pieces by the claimants for so many
different languages? But by these, says he, as by laws publicly
promulgated, it is shown that God made names exactly suited to the
nature of the things which they represent. What a grand doctrine! What
grand views our theologian allows to the Divine teachings, such indeed
as men do not grudge even to bathing-attendants! For we allow them to
give names to the operations they engage in, and yet no one invests
them with Divine honours for the invention of such names as foot-baths,
depilatories, towels, and the like—words which appropriately
designate the articles in question.