SECTION 3
James 1:19-27
MAN'S WRATH, GOD'S
James 1:19-20
19 Ye know this, my beloved brethren.---Whether this is an injunction, signifying, "know this," (imperative), or "ye know this," (indicative), cannot be definitely determined, inasmuch as the form for both constructions is the same, in this instance. It is likely that the Greek iste is to be construed as indicative; and, that it was James' design to point out that his readers were familiar with the fact to which he referred in the verses preceding, and he enjoins them to act accordingly. On this hypothesis, the meaning is: You are well aware of the fact that we were brought forth into spiritual life by the word of truth; therefore, let your life, in word and in deed, reflect the knowledge you have gamed therefrom. From a general statement of their knowledge of the noble ideals which should characterize them in their acknowledged familiarity with the word of truth, the writer proceeds to detail what such involves. Here, again, those addressed are the writer's "beloved brethren," a phrase repeatedly occurring in the Epistles. It indicates, (a) the same parentage ; (b) the closest kinship; ( c) deep and abiding affection.
But let every man be swift to bear, slow to speak, slow to wrath ----Here, the verb "let . .. be" (esto) is imperative. Jam es thus commands each of those to whom he wrote to be (a) swift to hear, (b) slow to speak; ( c) slow to wrath. The word "swift" is from the Greek tachus, occurring only ·here in the New Testament, and signifying that which is fleet of foot, quick, speedy ; and it introduces a remarkable phrase urging a fast and attentive mind, tachtts eis to (Jkousai, a ready disposition to listen. The second phrase, "slow to speak," is of similar construction, the meaning of which is, slow to begin speaking, not of course, slow while speaking! "To speak,'' is lalesai, ingressive aorist active infinitive. "Slow to wrath," follows the injunctions to be swift to hear and slow to speak. "Wrath," ( orgen) is violent emotion resulting in uncontrolled anger and improper indignation, and renders one thus possessed wholly incapable of receiving the word of truth without which one cannot be saved. Men will not, and cannot, properly listen to God when they entertain bitterness, malice, and hatred in their hearts toward their fellows. While it is likely that these words of James primarily refer to hearing the word of God, in a secondary sense they are applicable also to that which we hear from others.
The disposition to speak rashly and thoughtlessly and not always to weigh one's words is a besetting sin of many races and was especially characteristic of the Jewish people of the period in which James wrote. There is, therefore, much teaching in the Scriptures regarding the proper use of the tongue. (Proverbs 13:3; Proverbs 14:29; Proverbs 17:27; Ecclesiastes 5:2); and to this subject James himself devoted considerable space (James 1:26; James 3:1-18; James 4:11-12; James 5:9). It has often been observed that the writer, in this passage, gives us his version of the maxim, "Speech is silver; silence is golden." Ancient writers, both sacred and profane, have often dwelt upon the importance of constant vigilance in speech, and many interesting and pithy sayings have come down to us expressing sentiments similar to that of James: "Men have two ears, and but one tongue, that they should hear more than they speak." "The ears are always open, ever ready to receive instruction; but the tongue is surrounded with a double row of teeth, to hedge it in and to keep it within proper bounds." "How noble was the response of Xenocrates ! When he met the reproaches of others with a profound silence, some one asked him why he alone was silent. 'Because,' says he, 'I have sometimes had occasion to regret that I have spoken, never that I was silent. . . .' " "Talk little, and work much."
Socrates, the great Greek philosopher and educator, was once approached by a young fellow who asked the ancient sage to teach him oratory. The young man rattled away at great length; and when, at last, the philosopher was able to speak, he informed the voluble fellow that he would be required to charge him a double fee. "Why a double fee?" he asked. "Because," the famous teacher replied, "I shall have to teach you two sciences; first, how to hold your tongue, and second, how to use it." ·
Solomon said, "In the multitude of words there wanteth not transgression; but he that refraineth his lips doeth wisely." (Proverbs 10:19.) "He that guardeth his mouth keepeth his life; but he that openeth wide his lips shall have destruction." (Proverbs 13:3.) "See thou a man that is hasty in his words? There is more hope of a fool than of him." (Proverbs 29:20.) The degree to which one adheres to the precept, "Swift to hear, slow to speak, slow to wrath," will, in large measure, reveal how stable one's character is. The respect people are disposed to give to our opinions will depend largely on the amount of thought we give to the utterance of these opinions-and not the rapidity with which we express them ! And, those who are impatient of the views of others, and who can scarcely refrain from the expression of their own, will quickly be regarded as uncharitable and unthoughful of others, and possessed of much conceit and immodesty themselves.
20 for the wrath of man worketh not the righteousness of God.-This is the reason the Holy Spirit assigns why we are to be "swift to hear, slow to speak, slow to wrath." Those who are full of wrath (violent, mental agitation, resulting in uncontrolled anger), are wholly unequipped to listen to the presentation of the truth; or, for that matter, to do anything that is right. One of the most famous of the Old Testament's maxims of conduct is expressed by Micah as follows: "He hath showed thee, 0 man, what is good ; and what doth Jehovah require of thee, but to do justly, and to love kindness, and to walk humbly with thy God?" (Micah 6:8). One who is a battleground of violent passion finds it impossible to conform to this standard of right; and the conflict which rages in such a person makes it far more difficult for those about him to serve God acceptably. A "man's wrath," (so the Greek phrase runs), is put in contrast with "the righteousness of God." The wrath described here differs from "righteous indignation," which is, on some occasions, proper; condemned here is personal anger which, when it boils up and over, makes it impossible for those thus possessed to "work the righteousness of God," that is, the righteousness which God requires.
What is "the righteousness of God" (dikaiosmien Theou)? Thayer, in an unusually fine statement, says that righteousness, "denotes the state acceptable to God which becomes a sinner's possession through that faith by which he embraces the grace of God offered him in the expiatory death of Jesus Christ." By faith, this lexicographer means "a conviction, full of joyful trust, that Jesus is the Messiah-the divinely appointed author of eternal salvation in the kingdom of God, conjoined with obedience to Christ." The same authority says that righteousness (dikaiosime) in "the broad sense," is the state of one "who is such as he ought to be, ... the condition acceptable to God." It is, then, simply and solely a state of justification established on the basis of the sacrifice of Christ and man's acceptance thereof through the conditions required.
This lexical definition is completely and fully confirmed by affirmations of inspired writers. "Then Peter opened his mouth, and said, Of a truth I perceive that God is no respecter of persons: but in every nation he that feareth him, and worketh righteousness, is accepted with him." (Acts 10:34-35.) Righteousness is thus that state or condition wherein one is in a right relationship with God. Our English word "righteousness," derives from the word "right," which, in turn, literally suggests that which is straight (as, for example, a straight line), and so designates a relationship with God which he approves. A "righteous man" is, therefore, one who is straight, lined up properly with God! (Psalms 119:172; 1 John 2:29.)
A simple and brief definition of righteousness is, therefore, right-doing; to be righteous one must do right. "He that doeth righteousness is righteous, even as he is righteous." (1 John 3:7.) Of a certain type of character it is affirmed that he is righteous. Who is he? He that doeth righteousness. No other is. He who does righteousness is righteous; but he who is righteous is one who does right; therefore, he who does right possesses righteousness. Conversely, an unrighteous person is a perverse one ; a perverse one is an individual in a twisted (as opposed to a straight) relationship with God. It is hence clear that righteousness is that state or condition wherein one is approved of God; but God approves of those only who do right (keep his commandments) ; therefore, to possess the approval of God and the righteousness which he requires one must do right, by keeping his commandments.
Here is unmistakable evidence of the falsity of the denominational doctrine of transferred righteousness. It is by some alleged that in the process of conversion Christ transfers to the sinner the righteousness which he possesses, and thenceforth the sinner is clothed in the righteousness which Christ himself exhibits I One can only sadly wonder what the future holds for us as more and more writers among us, following the lead of denominational theologians, adopt the view of an imputation of righteousness on this basis, an idea repugnant to both reason and Scripture. It is absurd to assume that one person is good because another is. True, through the merits of Christ's blood shed in our behalf, our guilt is cancelled and through obedience to his will we are privileged to go free ; but this is far from declaring that we thereupon become positively good in the absence of good works. There is a vast difference between (a) not imputing guilt (this, the Lord does for us) and (b) in conferring merit (this, the Lord does not) in the process of salvation. The primary import of the word translated righteousness indicates a change in position and in relationship to God, and not, on that basis alone, a life of personal purity.
A pardoned criminal is no longer regarded as guilty of the crimes which led to his arrest and conviction, but he is thence by no means a valuable citizen with a long record of civic goodness back of him simply because he has been pardoned. Righteousness is right-doing. To be righteous, one must do right.
But, was not Abraham's faith reckoned (imputed, ·counted) to him for righteousness? Yes. In the absence of further duties at the moment God accepted Abraham's faith as an act of righteousness itself. Thus faith itself became the act of obedience, on the basis of which God accepted Abraham as in a right relationship with him. (James 2:20-22.) Did not David speak of "the blessedness of the man, unto whom God imputeth righteousness without works?" (Romans 4:6.) The works contemplated here (as the context clearly shows) were the works of the law. The man to whom the Lord imputes righteousness is the one whose "iniquities are forgiven, and whose sins are covered." (Psalms 32:1-2; Romans 4:8.) Such a one actively complies with God's plan for his forgiveness, and is thus declared righteous (justified.) We must distinguish between a righteousness imputed to (credited to) man because he has a right relationship with God through obedience to his will, and a righteousness which Christ (through his own submission to the will of the Father), is alleged to transfer to the sinner. The former the New Testament teaches; the latter is Calvinism.
But was not Christ made "righteousness" for us? (1 Corinthians 1:30.) The Lord became the means of righteousness for us; i.e., it is through him that we are privileged to receive "the gift of righteousness" (Romans 5:17); but this is accomplished through compliance with his will, and in obedience to his commandments, and not through some mysterious bestowal of merit. We should ever remember that justification does not eliminate the fact of sin ; it simply releases the sinner from the guilt thereof. The history of the act must forevermore remain. Paul, though mindful of the great grace which he had experienced, was never without the consciousness of the fact that he had persecuted the church of God and wasted it. Pardoned, saved, justified, acquitted, no longer under guilt, it now remained for him, through faithful adherence to the Lord's will to exhibit personal righteousness, "right standing'' with God. And so with us all.
The marvelous blessing of salvation is available through Christ. He is the means of righteousness, through him we receive the gift of righteousness, and in him we partake of God's righteousness ; i.e., the righteousness which God makes available to us, through unswerving allegiance to his will. The law of Moses was powerless to provide justification. It provided a perfect standard to which man, in sin, could never measure. A measuring cup will indicate the amount of the substance it contains, but it will not increase it; a tapeline will reveal the length of a string, but it cannot make it longer. It was, therefore, necessary that justification "apart from the law" be provided for man.
This, we .rejoice to say, was accomplished in Christ.