62. If then there is another Word of God, then be
the Son originated by a word; but if there be not, as is the case, but
all things by Him have come to be, which the Father has willed, does
not this expose the many-headed 64,
note 4. craftiness of
these men? that feeling shame at saying ‘work,’ and
‘creature,’ and ‘God’s Word was not before His
generation,’ yet in another way they assert that He is a
creature, putting forward ‘will,’ and saying, ‘Unless
He has by will come to be, therefore God had a Son by necessity and
against His good pleasure.’ And who is it then who imposes
necessity on Him, O men most wicked, who draw everything to the purpose
of your heresy? for what is contrary to will they see; but what is
greater and transcends it has escaped their perception. For as what is
beside purpose is contrary to will, so what is according to nature
transcends and precedes counselling Thus
he makes the question a nugatory one, as if it did not go to the point,
and could not be answered, or might be answered either way, as the case
might be. Really Nature and Will go together in the Divine Being, but
in order, as we regard Him, Nature is first, Will second, and the
generation belongs to Nature, not to Will. And so supr.
Or. i. 29; ii. 2. In like manner S. Epiphanius, Hær.
69, 26. vid. also Ancor. 51. vid. also Ambros. de Fid.
iv. 4. vid. others, as collected in Petav. Trin. vi. 8.
§§14–16.. A man by
counsel builds a house, but by nature he begets a son; and what is in
building began to come into being at will, and is external to the
maker; but the son is proper offspring of the father’s essence,
and is not external to him; wherefore neither does he counsel
concerning him, lest he appear to counsel about himself. As far then as
the Son transcends the creature, by so much does what is by nature
transcend the will Two
distinct meanings may be attached to ‘by will’ (as Dr.
Clark observes, Script. Doct. p. 142. ed. 1738), either a
concurrence or acquiescence, or a positive act. S. Cyril uses it in the
former sense, when he calls it σύνδρομος, as quoted §60, n. 1; and when he says (with Athan.
infr.) that ‘the Father wills His own subsistence,
θεληγής
ἐστι, but is not what He
is from any will, ἐκ
βουλήσεως
τινός,’
Thes. p. 56; Dr. Clark would understand it in the latter sense,
with a view of inferring that the Son was subsequent to a Divine act,
i.e. not eternal; but what Athan. says leads to the conclusion, that it
does not matter which sense is taken. He does not meet the Arian
objection, ‘if not by will therefore by necessity,’ by
speaking of a concomitant will, or merely saying that the Almighty
exists or is good, by will, with S. Cyril, but he says that
‘nature transcends will and necessity also.’
Accordingly, Petavius is even willing to allow that the ἐκ
βουλῆς is to be
ascribed to the γέννησις in the sense which Dr. Clark wishes, i.e. he grants that it
may precede the γέννησις, i.e. in order, not in time, in the succession of
our ideas, Trin. vi. 8, §§20, 21; and follows S.
Austin, Trin. xv. 20. in preferring to speak of our Lord rather
as voluntas de voluntate, than, as Athan. is led to do, as the voluntas
Dei.. And they, on
hearing of Him, ought not to
measure by will what is by nature; forgetting however that they are
hearing about God’s Son, they dare to apply human contrarieties
in the instance of God, ‘necessity’ and ‘beside
purpose,’ to be able thereby to deny that there is a true Son of
God. For let them tell us themselves,—that God is good and
merciful, does this attach to Him by will or not? if by will, we must
consider that He began to be good, and that His not being good is
possible; for to counsel and choose implies an inclination two ways,
and is incidental to a rational nature. But if it be too unseemly that
He should be called good and merciful upon will, then what they have
said themselves must be retorted on them,—‘therefore by
necessity and not at His pleasure He is good;’ and, ‘who is
it that imposes this necessity on Him?’ But if it be unseemly to
speak of necessity in the case of God, and therefore it is by nature
that He is good, much more is He, and more truly, Father of the Son by
nature and not by will.