On the one hand, we find him insisting on the right of
private judgment, as when he discusses the overruling Providence in
Julian’s life, and especially on the infatuation which led the
emperor to Persia in spite of Sallust (vi. 1): “This observation,
however, is only inserted lest I should be blamed for omitting it. I
leave every one to form his own opinion.” So, after discussing
the use of penance, he remarks in the following chapter (vii. 17):
“Such subjects as the above, however, are best left to the
decision of individual judgment.” He would also allow latitude in
ceremonials (vii. 19), as we shall see. On the other hand, he dreads
the progressive and unsettling outcome of the private judgment in
exercise. He expresses this fear in iv. 27: “The spirit of
innovation is self-laudatory; hence it advanced farther and farther,
and crept along to greater novelties. With increasing self-conceit, and
in scorn of the fathers, it enacted laws of its own. Nor does it honor
the doctrine of the ancients concerning God, but is always excogitating
strange dogmas and restlessly adds novelty to novelty, as the events
now show.”