The same subordinationism may be clearly seen in the writings of Dionysius of Alexandria
and of Gregory Thaumaturgus, two of Origen’s greatest disciples. It must not be forgotten
that at the beginning of the fourth century the problem of how to preserve the Godhood of
Christ and at the same time his subordination to the Father (in opposition to the monarchi-
anists) had not been solved. Eusebius in his earlier writings shows that he holds both (he
cannot be convicted of denying Christ’s divinity), but that he is as far from a solution of the
problem, and is just as uncertain in regard to the exact relation of Father and Son, as Tertul-
lian, Hippolytus, Origen, Dionysius, and Gregory Thaumaturgus were; is just as inconsistent
in his modes of expression as they, and yet no more so (see Harnack’s Dogmengeschichte,
I. pp. 628 sq. and 634 sq., for an exposition of the opinions of these other Fathers on the
subject). Eusebius, with the same immature and undeveloped views which were held all
through the third century, wrote those earlier works which have given rise to so much dispute
between those who accuse him of Arianism and those who defend him against the charge.
When he wrote them he was neither Arian nor Athanasian, and for that reason passages
may be found in them which if written after the Council of Nicæa might prove him an Arian,
and other passages which might as truly prove him an Athanasian, just as in the writings of
Origen were found by both parties passages to support their views, and in Gregory Thau-
maturgus passages apparently teaching Arianism, and others teaching its opposite, Sabel-
lianism (see Harnack, ib. p. 646).
Let us suppose now that Eusebius, holding fast to the divinity of Christ, and yet convinced
just as firmly of his subordination to the Father, becomes acquainted through Arius, or
other like-minded disciples of Lucian of Antioch, with a doctrine which seems to preserve
the Godhood, while at the same time emphasizing strongly the subordination of the Son,
and which formulates the relation of Father and Son in a clear and rational manner. That
he should accept such a doctrine eagerly is just what we should expect, and just what we
find him doing. In his epistles to Alexander and Euphration, he shows himself an Arian,
15
and Arius and his followers were quite right in claiming him as a supporter. There is that
in the epistles which is to be found nowhere in his previous writings, and which distinctly
separates him from the orthodox party. How then are we to explain the fact that a few years
later he signed the Nicene creed and anathematized the doctrines of Arius? Before we can
understand his conduct, it is necessary to examine carefully the two epistles in question.
Such an examination will show us that what Eusebius is defending in them is not genuine
Arianism. He evidently thinks that it is, evidently supposes that he and Arius are in complete
agreement upon the subjects under discussion; but he is mistaken. The extant fragments of
the two epistles are given below on p. 70. It will be seen that Eusebius in them defends the
Arian doctrine that there was a time when the Son of God was not. It will be seen also that
he finds fault with Alexander for representing the Arians as teaching that the “Son of God
was made out of nothing, like all creatures,” and contends that Arius teaches that the Son
24
The Outbreak of the Arian Controversy. The Attitude of Eusebius.