The feeling against Marcellus might have been
less strong, at any rate it would have had less show of reason, but for
the fact that he was the teacher of Photinus.
This person became bishop of Sirmium between 330 and 340, gave great
offence by his teaching, and was deposed by the Arian party
ineffectually in 347, finally in 351. After his expulsion he occupied
himself with writing books in Greek and in Latin, including a work
‘against all heresies,’ in which he expounded his own
(Socr. ii. 30). None of his works have survived, and our information is
very scanty (Zahn, Marc. 189–196 is the best account), but
he seems to have solved the central difficulty of Marcellus by placing
the seat of the Personality of Christ in His Human Soul. How much of
the system of his master he retained is uncertain, but the result was
in substance pure Unitarianism. It is instructive to observe that even
Photinus was passively supported for a time by the Nicenes. He was
apparently (Hil. Fr. ii. 19, sqq.) condemned at a council
at Milan in 345, but not at Rome till 380. Athanasius (pp.
444–447) abstains from mentioning his name although he refutes
his opinions; once only he mentions him as a heretic, and with apparent
reluctance (c. Apoll. ii. 19, τοῦ
λεγομένου
φωτεινοῦ). The first But he is
condemned by name in the alleged Coptic Acts of the Council of 362;
moreover Eustathius appears to have written against him, see Cowper,
Syr. Misc. 60. condemnation of him on the Nicene side in the
East is by Paulinus of Antioch in 362 (p. 486). On the other hand the
Eusebians eagerly caught at so irresistible a weapon. Again and again
they hurled anathemas at Photinus, at first simply identifying him with
Marcellus, but afterwards with full appreciation of his position. And
even to the last the new Nicene party in Asia were aggrieved at the
refusal of the old Nicenes at Alexandria and Rome to anathematise the
master of such a heretic. Photinus was the scandal of Marcellus,
Marcellus of the Council of Nicæa.