The
only one of these—“that furnished posterity with means of
defense against heresies”—whom Eusebius mentions is Agrippa
Castor, and it is evident that he knew of no others. Moreover, it is
more than doubtful whether Agrippa Castor belonged to that time. We do
not know when he wrote, but it is hardly possible that the Church had
at that period any one capable of answering such a work as the
Commentary of Basilides, or any one who would wish to if he could. The
activity of the Church was at this early period devoted chiefly if not
wholly to the production of apologies for the defense of the Church
against the attacks of enemies from the outside, and to the composition
of apocalypses. Eusebius in the next chapter mentions Hegesippus as
another of these “writers of the time.” But the passage
which he quotes to prove that Hegesippus wrote then only proves that
the events mentioned took place during his lifetime, and not
necessarily within forty or fifty years of the time at which he was
writing. The fact is, that Hegesippus really wrote about 175 a.d. (later therefore than Justin Martyr), and in
chap. 21 of this book Eusebius restores him to his proper chronological
place. The general statement made here by Eusebius in regard to the
writers against heresy during the reign of Hadrian rest upon his
preconceived idea of what must have been the case. If the devil raised
up enemies against the truth, the Church must certainly have had at the
same time defenders to meet them. It is a simple example of
well-meaning subjective reconstruction. He had the work of Agrippa
Castor before him, and undoubtedly believed that he lived at the time
stated (which indeed we cannot absolutely deny), and believed,
moreover, that other similar writers, whose names he did not know,
lived at the same time.