Though Nestorius was deposed his
friends protested that they would continue true to him, and Theodoret
was one of the synod held at Tarsus, and of another at Antioch, in
which the protest against Cyril’s action was renewed. But the
oriental bishops were now themselves undergoing a process of
scission, Hefele.
Hist. Consc. iii. 127. Can. Venables. Dict. Christ. Biog. iv.
910. John of Antioch and Acacius of Berœa
heading the peacemakers who were anxious to come to terms with Cyril,
while Alexander of Hierapolis led the irreconcilables. Intellectually
Theodoret shrank from concession, but his moral instincts were all in
favour of peace. He himself drew up a declaration of faith which was
presented by Paul of Emesa to Cyril, which Cyril accepted. But still
true to his friend, Theodoret refused to accept the deposition of
Nestorius and his individual condemnation, and it was not till several
years had elapsed that, moved less by the threat of exile and
forfeiture, as the imperial penalty for refusing to accept the
position, than by the entreaties of his beloved flock and of his
favourite ascetic solitaries that he would not leave them, Theodoret
found means of attaching a meaning to the current anathemas on
Nestorianism, not, as he said, on Nestorius, which allowed him to
submit. He even entered into friendly correspondence with Cyril. Ep.
lxxxiii. But the truce was hollow. Cyril was indignant
to find that Theodoret still maintained his old opinions. At last the
protracted quarrel was ended by Cyril’s death in June,
444.