235
Chapter XVIII.—The Manner in which Apollonius refuted the Phrygians, and the Per-
sons1617whom he Mentions.
1. As the so-called Phrygian heresy1618 was still flourishing in Phrygia in his time,
Apollonius1619 also, an ecclesiastical writer, undertook its refutation, and wrote a special
work against it, correcting in detail the false prophecies current among them and reproving
the life of the founders of the heresy. But hear his own words respecting Montanus:
2. “His actions and his teaching show who this new teacher is. This is he who taught
the dissolution of marriage;1620 who made laws for fasting;1621 who named Pepuza and
1617 Or events (τίνων).
1618 On the name, see chap. 16, note 2.
1619 Of this Apollonius we know little more than what Eusebius tells us in this chapter. The author of
Prædestinatus (in the fifth century) calls him bishop of Ephesus, but his authority is of no weight. Jerome devotes
chap. 40 of his de vir. ill. to Apollonius, but it is clear that he derives his knowledge almost exclusively from
Eusebius. He adds the notice, however, that Tertullian replied to Apollonius’ work in the seventh book of his
own work, de Ecstasi(now lost). The character of Apollonius’ work may be gathered from the fragments preserved
by Eusebius in this chapter. It was of the same nature as the work of the anonymous writer quoted in chap. 16,
very bitter in tone and not over-scrupulous in its statements. Apollonius states (see in §12, below) that he wrote
the work forty years after the rise of Montanism. If we accepted the Eusebian date for its beginning (172), this
would bring us down to 212, but (as remarked above, in chap. 16, note 12) Montanism had probably begun in
a quiet way sometime before this, and so Apollonius’ forty years are perhaps to be reckoned from a somewhat
earlier date. His mention of “the prophetess” as still living (in §6, below) might lead us to think that Maximilia
was still alive when he wrote; but when the anonymous wrote she was already dead, and the reasons for assigning
the latter to a date as early as 192 are too strong to be set aside. We must therefore suppose Apollonius to be
referring to some other prophetess well known in his time. That there were many such prophetesses in the early
part of the third century is clear from the works of Tertullian. Jerome (ibid.) states that an account of the death
of Montanus and his prophetesses by hanging was contained in Apollonius’ work, but it has been justly suspected
that he is confusing the work of the anonymous, quoted in chap. 16, above, with the work of Apollonius, quoted
in this chapter. The fragments of Apollonius’ work, preserved by Eusebius, are given, with a commentary, in
Routh’s Rel. Sac. I. p. 467 sq., and an English translation in the Ante-Nicene Fathers, VIII. p. 775 sq.
1620 We are not to gather from this that the Montanists forbade marriage. They were, to be sure, decidedly
ascetic in their tendencies, and they did teach the unlawfulness of second marriages,—which had long been
looked upon with disfavor in many quarters, but whose lawfulness the Church had never denied,—and magnified
the blessedness of the single state; but beyond this they did not go, so far as we are able to judge. Our chief
sources for the Montanistic view of marriage are Tertullian’s works ad Uxorem, de Pudicit., de Monogamia, de
Exhort. ad castitat., and Epiphanius’ Hær. XLVIII. 9.
1621 One great point of dispute between the Montanists and the Catholics was the subject of fasts (cf. Hip-
polytus, VIII. 12, X. 21, who makes it almost the only ground of complaint against the Montanists). The
Montanist prophetesses ordained two new fasts of a week each in addition to the annual paschal fast of the
The Manner in which Apollonius refuted the Phrygians, and the Persons whom he Mentions.
557
The Manner in which Apollonius refuted the Phrygians, and the Persons whom…