Hilary Bishop of Pictavium Poictiers. was a believer in the Catholic
doctrine, and wrote a very complete work of instruction with the view
of bringing back from their error those who had subscribed the
faithless creed of Ariminum. There seem to be no means of throwing light upon this story.
Hilary was not at the council of Ariminum, but at that of Seleucia,
held the same year (359). On his return to Gaul in 361 he endeavoured,
in various meetings of bishops to reunite with the Homoousians those
who had subscribed the creed of Ariminum. (See Art. on Hilary Pictav.
in Dict. of Christ. Biography.) It may have been in one of these
meetings that this scene occurred. This book fell
into the hands of his adversaries and ill wishers, whether, as some
said, by bribing his secretary, or by no matter what other cause. He
knew nothing of this: but the book was so falsified by them, the
saintly man being all the while entirely unconscious of it, that, when
his enemies began to accuse him of heresy in the episcopal assembly, as
holding what they knew they had corruptly inserted in his manuscript,
he himself demanded the production of his book as evidence of his
faith. It was brought from his house, and was found to be full of
matter which he repudiated: but it caused him to be excommunicated and
to be excluded from the meeting of the synod. In this case, however,
though the crime was one of unexampled wickedness, the man who was the
victim of it was alive, and present in the flesh; and the hostile
faction could be convicted and brought to punishment, when their tricks
became known and their machinations were exposed. A remedy was applied
through statements, explanations, and similar things: for living men
can take action on their own behalf, the dead can refute no accusations
under which they labour.