Moreover, when in discussing digamy and trigamy I have
said, Ag. Jov. i. 14. “It is better for a woman to know
one man, even though he be a second husband or a third, than several;
it is more tolerable for her to prostitute herself to one man than to
many,” have I not immediately subjoined my reason for so saying?
“The Samaritan woman in the Gospel, when she declares that her
present husband is her sixth, is rebuked by the Lord on the ground that
he is not her husband.” Joh. iv. 16–18. Jerome’s version of the story is
inaccurate. For my own part, I
now once more freely proclaim that digamy is not condemned in the
Church—no, nor yet trigamy—and that a woman may marry a
fifth husband, or a sixth, or a greater number still just as lawfully
as she may marry a second; but that, while such marriages are not
condemned, neither are they commended. They are meant as alleviations
of an unhappy lot, and in no way redound to the glory of continence. I
have spoken to the same effect elsewhere. Ag. Jov. i. 15.
“When a woman marries more than once—whether she does so
twice or three times matters little—she ceases to be a
monogamist. ‘All things are lawful…but all things are not
expedient.’ 1 Cor. vi. 12. I do not condemn
digamists or trigamists, or even, to put an impossible case,
octogamists. Let a woman have an eighth husband if she must; only let
her cease to prostitute herself.”