(1) 318: *Two books ‘contra Gentes,’
viz. c. Gent. and De
Incarn. (2) 321–2: *Depositio Arii (on its authorship, see
Introd.) (3) 328–373: *Festal Letters.
(4) 328–335? *Ecthesis or Expositio
Fidei. (5) Id.? *In Illud Omnia, etc.
(6) 339: *Encyclica ad Episcopos ecclesiæ
catholicæ. (7) 343: *Sardican Letters
(46, 47, in this vol.). (8) 351? *Apologia Contra
Arianos. (9) 352? *De Decretis Concilii
Nicæni, with the *Epistola Eusebii (a.d. 325) as appendix. (10) Id.? *De Sententia Dionysii. (11) 350–353? *Ad Amun, (Letter 48). (12) 354: *Ad
Dracontium (Letter 49 in this vol.). (13) 356–362? *Vita Antoni. (14) 356: *Epistola ad Episc. Ægypti et Libyæ. (15) 356–7: *Apol. ad Constantium. (16) 357: *Apol. de Fuga. (17) 358: *Epist. ad
Serapionem de Morte Arii (Letter 54). (18) ID. *Two Letters to Monks (52,
53). (19) 358? *Historia Arianorum ‘ad
monachos.’ (20) Id. *Orationes adversus
Arianos IV. (21) 359? *Ad Luciferum
(Letters 50, 51). (22) Id.? Ad Serapionem
Orationes IV. (Migne xxvi. 529, sqq.). These λόγοι or dogmatic letters are the
most important work omitted in the present volume. Serapion of Thmuis,
who appears from the silence respecting him in the lists of exiles to
have escaped banishment in 356–7, reported to Athanasius the
growth of the doctrine that, while the Son was co-essential with the
Father, the Spirit was merely a creature superior to Angels. Athanasius
replied in a long dogmatic letter, upon receiving which Serapion was
begged to induce the author to abridge it for the benefit of the
simple. After some hesitation Athanasius sent two more letters, the
second drawing out the proofs of the Godhead of the Son, the third
restating more concisely the argument of the first. The objections by
which these letters were met were replied to in a fourth letter which
Athanasius declared to be his last word. The persons combated are not
the Macedonians, who only formed a party on this question at a later
date, and whose position was not quite that combated in these letters.
Athanasius calls them Τροπικοί, or
‘Figurists,’ from the sense in
which they understood passages of Scripture which seemed to deify the
Holy Spirit. It is not within our compass to summarise the treatises,
but it may be noted that Ath. argues that where πνεῦμα is absolute or
anarthrous in Scripture it never refers to the Holy Spirit unless the
context already supplies such reference (i. 4, sqq.). He meets
the objection that the Spirit, if God and of God, must needs be a Son,
by falling back upon the language of Scripture as our guide where human
analogies fail us. He also presses his opponents with the consequence
that they substitute a Dyad for a Trinity. In the fourth letter, at the request of
Serapion, he gives an explanation of the words of Christ about Sin Against the Spirit. Rejecting the view (Origen,
Theognostus) that post-baptismal sin is meant (§§9,
sqq.), as favouring Novatianist rigour, he examines the
circumstances under which our Lord uttered the warning. The Pharisees
refused to regard the Lord as divine when they saw His miracles, but
ascribed them to Beelzebub. They blasphemed ‘the Spirit,’
i.e. the Divine Personality of Christ (§19, cf. Lam. iv. 20, LXX.). So far as the words relate to
the Holy Spirit, it is not because the Spirit worked through Him (as
through a prophet) but because He worked through the Spirit (20).
Blasphemy against the Spirit, then, is blasphemy against Christ in its
worst form (see also below, ch. iv., §6). It may be noted lastly
that he refers to Origen in the same terms of somewhat measured praise
(ὁ πολυμαθὴς
καὶ
φιλόπονος), as in the
De Decretis.