48. Such then, as we confess and believe, being
the sense of the Fathers, proceed we even in their company to examine
once more the matter, calmly and with a kindly sympathy, with reference
to what has been said before, viz. whether the Bishops collected at
Nicæa do not really prove to have thought aright. For if the Word
be a work and foreign to the Father’s essence, so that He is
separated from the Father by the difference of nature, He cannot be one
in essence with Him, but rather He is homogeneous by nature with the
works, though He surpass them in grace De
Decr. §1..
On the other hand, if we confess that He is not a work but the genuine
offspring of the Father’s essence, it would follow that He is
inseparable from the Father, being connatural, because He is begotten
from Him. And being such, good reason He should be called Coessential.
Next, if the Son be not such from
participation, but is in His essence the Father’s Word and
Wisdom, and this essence is the offspring of the Father’s
essence §51, note., and its likeness as the radiance is
of the light, and the Son says, ‘I and the Father are One,’
and, ‘he that hath seen Me, hath seen the Father’ (John x. 30; xiv. 9), how must we understand these words? or
how shall we so explain them as to preserve the oneness of the Father
and the Son? Now as to its consisting in agreement §23, note 3, yet vid. Hipp. contr. Noet. 7. of doctrines, and in the Son’s not
disagreeing with the Father, as the Arians say, such an interpretation
is a sorry one; for both the Saints, and still more Angels and
Archangels, have such an agreement with God, and there is no
disagreement among them. For he who disagreed, the devil, was beheld to
fall from the heavens, as the Lord said. Therefore if by reason of
agreement the Father and the Son are one, there would be things
originated which had this agreement with God, and each of these might
say, ‘I and the Father are One.’ But if this be absurd, and
so it truly is, it follows of necessity that we must conceive of
Son’s and Father’s oneness in the way of essence. For
things originate, though they have an agreement with their Maker, yet
possess it only by influence κινήσει vid. Cyril. contr. Jul. viii. p. 274. Greg. Nyss. de
Hom. Op. p. 87., and by
participation, and through the mind; the transgression of which
forfeits heaven. But the Son, being an offspring from the essence, is
one by essence, Himself and the Father that begat Him.