The Donatists of Cirta, clergy and people, had returned to the Catholic Church and had
written a letter of thanks to Augustin for his preaching, under which they had been persuaded
to renounce the schism. Augustin in reply [Ep. cxliv.], probably at end of 412 A.D., says
that this is not man’s work, but God’s. Their allusion to the conversion of the drunken and
luxurious Polemo by Xenocrates, draws from him the reflection, that such a change of
character, though not a Christian repentance, is, nevertheless, a work of God. So he bids
them not to give thanks to himself but to God, for their return to the unity. Those who still
are alienated, whether from love or fear, he charges to remember the undeceived scrutiny
of God; to weigh Scripture testimony as to the universality of the Church; and the documents
as to the origin of the schism. The case has been tried or not been tried by the transmarine
churches; if not, then there is no existing ground for the separation; if it has, the defeated
ones are the separatists. But alas! the obstacles to their persuasion are well-nigh insuperable.
He hopes that the mutual desire for his visit to them may be fulfilled.
About the beginning of the year 413, appeared the book De Fide et Operibus. In Chap.
iv. 6, he speaks of the need of coercion against the Donatists as disturbers of the peace of
the Church, as separaters of the tares from the wheat before the time, as those who have
blindly preferred to cut themselves off from the unity; commixture of evil and good is a
necessity, and we ought to remain in that fellowship which is not at all destitute of discipline.
[Cp. Retractt. II. xxxviii.]
Donatus, a Donatist presbyter, and another person connected with that body, had been
arrested by order of Augustin about the beginning of 416 A.D. Mounted upon a beast
against his will, he dashed himself to the ground and so received injuries which his less ob-
stinate companion escaped. Augustin writes [Ep. clxxiii.] to vindicate himself as concerned
about the salvation of the recusants, and puts the blame of the wounds upon the offender.
Donatus urged in opposition to this style of conversion that no one should be compelled to
be good. Augustin claims on the other hand that many are compelled to take the good office
of a bishop against their will. Donatus argues that God had given us free will, therefore a
man should not be compelled even to be good. Augustin replies that the effort of a good
will is to restrain and change the evil will, because of the awful results which follow a vitiated
will. Why were the Israelites compelled to go to the land of promise? Why was Paul forced
to turn from persecution to the embrace of the truth? Why do parents correct children?
Why are negligent shepherds blamed? You are an errant sheep, with the Lord’s mark upon
399
you, and I as shepherd must save you from perishing. Of your own will you threw yourself
into a well, but it would have been wicked to leave you there where you had cast yourself
according to your will, and hence the attendants took you out; how much more is it a duty
to save you from eternal death. Besides, it is unlawful to inflict death upon yourself. He
reminds him that the Scriptures do not allow suicide; and controverts his use of I. Cor. xiii.
3, "though I give my body to be burned." Severed from charity and unity, nothing can profit,
681
An Analysis of Augustin’s Writings Against the Donatists.